Evidence of meeting #50 for Procedure and House Affairs in the 41st Parliament, 2nd Session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was lords.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

MPs speaking

Also speaking

David Beamish  Clerk of the Parliaments, House of Lords of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

11:40 a.m.

Clerk of the Parliaments, House of Lords of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

David Beamish

Obviously, because of the need to respect the secrecy of the ballot we didn't let any students look at them to do that sort of analysis. What was made public was a chart showing the progress of the count as candidates were eliminated. As Mr. Reid implied, I suspect most of that is in the Wikipedia article, but I'd be happy to send your clerk PDF copies of the charts so that it would be possible to tell how many votes were dropped out because preferences had run out at every stage.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Wild Rose, AB

Thank you. It would be quite interesting if you could do that. I suspect you're probably right that it certainly would be an issue that would require some education. I think most people when they move to something new like that do have some trouble understanding its implications, so it would be interesting to know how many were dropping off. Then we would know how many places people were choosing.

Thank you very much.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Thank you, Mr. Richards.

Mr. Beamish, we thank you. We've run out of questions. We're happy that you were able to share with us today. I know Mr. Reid's very happy to get that information. We will now deliberate on what we'll do next. We thank you, first of all, for your patience with the inconvenience of the other day and for all the information you were able to share with us today.

11:40 a.m.

Clerk of the Parliaments, House of Lords of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

David Beamish

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. There was no problem coming back a week later. Should you think of any more factual information that would be helpful to the committee, if your clerk lets me know I'll do my best to help.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Thank you very much. Enjoy your evening.

11:40 a.m.

Clerk of the Parliaments, House of Lords of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Thank you.

Members, we have some time now and since we were denied the extension on this motion, I think we probably should get to it and work on it. I know we have Monsieur Godin next, and let's hope we can get one done before the other.

Yes?

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Tom Lukiwski Conservative Regina—Lumsden—Lake Centre, SK

Chair, are we going in camera if we're discussing the committee report?

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Yes. I was just about to do that. We will go into camera to discuss what we're going to do with Mr. Reid's motion. I believe Mr. Reid will be also excusing himself.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Scott Reid Conservative Lanark—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington, ON

That's right.

Do I get to say something before I excuse myself?

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Sure. Your last meal, your last statement, all of that stuff.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Scott Reid Conservative Lanark—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington, ON

I hadn't anticipated that this would come to be discussed at this point today.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Nor had I.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Scott Reid Conservative Lanark—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington, ON

So my office had been in the process of getting a translation done of Lord Tyler's blogging on the subject, which won't be available to us now. I think the clerk circulated his written submission to everybody.

11:40 a.m.

The Clerk

Yes.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

Scott Reid Conservative Lanark—Frontenac—Lennox and Addington, ON

Obviously, it tends to favour this kind of approach and I'm hoping that everyone will have a chance to look at it. It does deal with at least one of the pertinent questions and a direct comparison between the two systems. That's all I wanted to say. I will now excuse myself.

11:40 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Super.

I will suspend just for two minutes while we go in camera, please.

[Proceedings continue in camera]

12:05 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

All right. We'll call the meeting back to order.

We have a witness. Yvon Godin is here on a question of privilege. He rose in the House and it was accepted.

Yvon, you have a bit of an opening statement to tell us the facts and figures around it. I'd then like the members to be able to ask you a few questions, but we're on a really tight timetable today so we're going to try for about a half an hour's worth at best. Okay?

October 2nd, 2014 / 12:05 p.m.

NDP

Yvon Godin NDP Acadie—Bathurst, NB

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

I agree with that. I think I won't need much time to relate what happened.

First of all, I would like to thank you, Mr. Chair, as well as the members of the Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs, for hearing me today, so that I can speak about this incident which occurred on September 25, 2014.

I was in my office in the morning between 10:00 and 10:30 a.m. As all members know, a bell was heard in our offices and the lights went on. It was as though the police had turned on their headlights. This reminds us to go and vote. It reminds us of our responsibility as parliamentarians, which is to go to the House of Commons and vote.

And so I left my office and the Justice Building. I took the little green shuttle bus that brings the members to the House of Commons and back to their offices. When we arrived at the back of the Confederation Building, the green bus stopped. The driver told us that it would be better for us to get off since the cars had been stopped for a while. Indeed, the line went from the rear of the Confederation Building right up to the Royal Canadian Mounted Police post inside the gates. The line was already quite long, and the bus driver told us that we would not be able to get through.

So I got off the bus with my other colleagues who were also on board. We walked up to the entrance which is at the front or on the side of the Confederation Building. If you are on Bank Street and you look south, it is to your right, just in the entrance.

I arrived there and there was an RCMP officer on Bank Street. I told him that I had to go up to Parliament. He answered me in English: “Get on the sidewalk”.

I saw that he did not speak French. And so I replied to him in English, as follows:

“Well, I am a member of Parliament and I have to go up.”

He answered in a very serious manner. He said, “I don't care, and get on the sidewalk”. I had just moved off the sidewalk in coming up. My colleagues behind me were from all parties. There were members from the Conservative Party and the NDP. I said, “Well, there's a vote up there and I need to go.”

The invited guest was not in yet. They were waiting for the invited guest to come in. I think it was the president of Germany who was coming in. I said that I really needed to go in, that there was a vote. He said, “I just don't care if you have a vote.” I pushed it a little more. I said, “In your view, in your attitude, you don't care, but it could be a vote that could bring the government down, a vote like that.”

You know and we know how votes go. It could be a vote like that.

I was pushing it right to what it could be and to our responsibility, and I said, “It could be a vote of confidence.” He said: “I don't care about the Parliament. I don't care about your vote. Just stay there and you don't move.” I said to the officer, “Well, I can tell you this: you are wrong.” I made the decision at that time to back off.

At the same there was an officer from the city of Ottawa there, a woman with a motorcycle. She was off her motorcycle. She said, “Sir, get on the sidewalk.” I remember what I said to her. I said, “Don't get mixed up in this one here; I'm dealing with the RCMP.” But then I stayed. After that, he walked across with me and he walked across the road. He said, “I'm just doing that for your safety.” I said, “No, it's not right what you've done, and I don't agree.”

One of my colleagues, Kennedy Stewart, was there as a witness. He heard the officer doing it. Just this morning I spoke to Ruth Ellen Brosseau, and they had another incident on the bus at the same time. The bus chauffeur didn't even want her to get off the bus. They had to argue with the bus chauffeur and say that they had to get out, but it didn't work out, because they could not go through either. I also hear—and you could check—that the immigration minister, Chris Alexander, was stopped from going through.

I spoke to the Speaker of the House of Commons. He was stopped as well. I don't remember if it was Thursday or Friday morning. His car was even searched by the police. He was in a hurry to go and open the sitting at the House of Commons. He told the police he was the Speaker and that if he could not get up there, the House of Commons could not begin its work. Once again, the attitude displayed could be summarized in the following way: “That's just too bad, not our concern; you can't go up there.”

Mr. Chair, members of the committee, I think this was totally unacceptable. For the record, I want to remind all members of the committee of one definition of parliamentary privilege, which is as follows: “Pursuant to parliamentary privilege, the holder has full access at all times, without obstacle or interference, to the Chamber of the House of Commons the holder is a member of.” That is what constitutes our privilege.

I will go even further. The police are supposed to ensure the security of members, but if they don't recognize us and if something happens involving the public at large, we may wind up being the victims. This is a very important matter.

When Bill Blaikie sat in Parliament a similar situation occurred. The Standing Committee on Procedure and House Affairs studied the issue at the time. As you know, I was the NDP Whip at the time. The committee agreed that it was time for this to stop. Two years ago, in 2012, another incident occurred. Once again, we said that this had to stop. And yet, it happened again.

Mr. Chair, I have this privilege. I was elected by the citizens of the riding of Acadie-Bathurst to represent them. Parliament has its reasons to grant us a privilege which excludes interference. This implies the responsibility of letting us get in at all times.

I will simply add to that, openly, that the next time, I'm going to go through. They can deal with their problems. I'm going to take my privilege seriously.

12:10 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Monsieur Godin, thank you, merci for your comments today. You've done a good job of sharing with us, and I know that you and I sat on the procedure and House affairs committee one of the last times we looked at this privilege issue of members not being allowed to come to the House.

I'll take some questions from members, but let's try to keep it to the facts of the incident and not what we're going to do going forward. We have some reports and some other witnesses we'll likely call also.

Mr. Lukiwski, you're starting us.

12:10 p.m.

Conservative

Tom Lukiwski Conservative Regina—Lumsden—Lake Centre, SK

Yes, and I won't be very long, because I don't think anybody here disagrees with Yvon. We all know this shouldn't have happened. It should not happen in the future. Unfortunately, I think this was the third incident I can recall in the last six or seven years. What we need to do is to get right into calling witnesses.

As I mentioned in my intervention, Yvon, when you raised this in the House of Commons—

12:10 p.m.

NDP

Yvon Godin NDP Acadie—Bathurst, NB

Is the translation only not working for me?

12:10 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

I was getting translation from you very well.

12:15 p.m.

Conservative

Tom Lukiwski Conservative Regina—Lumsden—Lake Centre, SK

Can you hear me now, Yvon?

12:15 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Joe Preston

Go ahead, Mr. Lukiwski.