Business of Supply  Madam Chair, I actually want to know why the Conservatives voted against the Canada housing benefit, which is helping renters directly.

Business of Supply  Madam Chair, it is really difficult to take the party opposite seriously on this issue because it has no plan. What little ideas that the Conservatives bring are something that we have been doing for the last number of years.

Business of Supply  Madam Chair, that is exactly what the housing accelerator fund is trying to do. It is to speed up the permitting and delivery of housing. Unfortunately, the Conservatives did not support it.

Business of Supply  Madam Chair, the Conservatives can play these games all night if they wish. Different local municipalities have different timelines for permits.

Business of Supply   the beginning of the national housing strategy in 2017. Conservatives have just come around to the idea now. Even then, the idea is a very half-baked plan.

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, I think the hon. member is absolutely on brand in attacking civil servants, which is what the Conservatives did when they were in government for almost nine years. I am not going to take that bait. The hon. member knows or should know that no minister of the Crown

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, if they care about housing affordability, why did the Conservatives vote against the first-time homebuyer incentive?

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, why did the Conservatives vote against supports for homebuyers?

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, if the Conservatives are serious about rental supports, why did they vote against the Canada housing benefit, which is delivering real supports to Canadian renters?

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, the Conservatives have all the questions tonight, but they have no plan on housing, and they have no help for Canadians who actually need help with housing.

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, we know that one of the solutions to higher housing prices is more supply. We brought in measures to create more supply. The Conservatives voted against it.

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, do the Conservatives have a plan for housing, or do they just have rhetoric and buzzwords?

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, the Conservatives do not have a plan. All they have is gimmicks and buzzwords.

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, I do want to speak about housing. The problem is the Conservatives have no plan, and they stand here, pretending to care about Canadians and getting help to them, but they vote against all the measures we bring to this House.

Business of Supply  Mr. Chair, it is very perplexing. Conservatives talk about, for example, connecting housing to infrastructure. We have been doing that for two years. They talk about investing in municipalities and removing the obstacles to more supply. That is exactly what the housing