Industry committee  I will get that out of Hansard and pass it on to the statisticians to see if I can get the answers.

Industry committee  I can get your exact question out of Hansard.

Industry committee  When the Supreme Court of Canada decision came down in 2012 interpreting fair dealing broadly to say that copying short excerpts for student instruction was permitted or was fair, we were faced—“we” being legal counsel for colleges, universities, and the Council of Ministers of E

Industry committee  I just want to make one other point, because the fair dealing guidelines are a conservative interpretation of “short excerpt”. As for why they're conservative, around the world, if you want to go outside of Canada, in Israel there was a dispute between the higher education commun

Industry committee  We were in years of litigation with them. No, we did not, because there was no possibility of ever coming to an agreement. There still isn't today. That's what's before this committee. No.

Industry committee  Do you mean constant dollars? Yes.

Industry committee  I believe so. I asked the same question.

Industry committee  Constant dollars was the answer I was given to that question.

Industry committee  There are statisticians who work at the Council of Ministers. I'm not one. They produce the list.

Industry committee  I asked the question. That was the answer. Yes, it is in constant dollars.

Industry committee  If StatsCan has data on that, we could do it.

Industry committee  How changing with the CPI was one, and what dollar is the constant dollar?

Industry committee  What would the clarification be? Would it be on the 66%?

Industry committee  I certainly can. Your colleague beside you asked the same question. The decision to no longer rely on the Access Copyright tariff but other sources of copyright clearance has nothing to do with the adding of education to the list of purposes for which fair dealing can be engaged

Industry committee  You're trying to understand.