Mr. Stanton was on an interesting line of questioning. I'm not sure you answered what he was asking.
When Professor Attaran finally received his information, he wasn't satisfied. He thought that too much had been blacked out. So he asked you to reconsider the exemptions. Prior to going to the Information Commissioner and filing a complaint, there is an avenue of recourse by which the applicant can come back to the ATIP coordinator and ask that you reconsider those exemptions or provide further explanation.
To whom did you take all the names involved in the reconsideration, then?