Yes, in my presentation, I quoted the Supreme Court decision in the Charkaoui case, which restated the decision in the Sahin v. Canada case in 1995.
So it is impossible for foreign nationals to have the validity of their detention determined under sections 9 and 10(c) of the Canadian Charter. So prolonged detention without review or regular and effective determination of the detention runs counter to either section 7 of the charter or section 10.
So I would have said the same thing as my colleague and I would not have recommended a one-year automatic detention.