First, in response to your long, rambling question, I will provide you more than a one-word answer. This is another example of the way the Tories try to bully people into having a discussion on their terms. You put people in boxes and you try to paint them as villains. Frankly, I think it's undemocratic and unbecoming of a member of Parliament.
In response to your comment about disparaging our resources--and in that regard I think you're talking about the resources of Alberta--I am not trying to disparage either the oil sands or any of the people who have worked with them. What I am disparaging is your government's approach to developing those resources, which I think is irresponsible.