When we deal with this question of notice and notice, we have two fundamental problems.
On the one hand, an ISP has a difficulty being an arbiter and deciding when there's infringement and when there's not. That's the problem with notice and takedown, obviously: they're asking the ISP to be the arbiter.
The other problem, of course, is that for a creator, particularly a small artist, to enforce with a lawsuit every single infringement of their copyright is obviously impractical and impossible. The problem, then, is how to reduce the amount of copyright fraud—infringement—and at the same time ensure that artists get compensated? One witness suggested that we need to have some kind of made-in-Canada solution that overcomes that, particularly for smaller players.
Do you have anything in mind that might work?