I definitely agree with what was said on private copying and training. However, we also have to look at all the studies that have been done.
In many other countries, studies were done. For example, in England, there was a study conducted with Google on illegal services. Actually, rather than use the word “illegal”, let us say services for which music is being used without rights being granted. Support must be provided through subsidies. Those are the studies that must be reviewed.
The other thing that must also be reviewed is the balance with respect to the value of a creation. In Europe, there is a major discussion going on about forecasting the value of music and intermediaries. Questions are being asked about the role they play and the social role they must play when it comes to creation.
Understandably, technological development has been emphasized. But without content, technological development is nothing. Content is the base. It is the roots of the tree which must blossom. So, certain things must be looked at. We must investigate the value of music and the way it is shared between stakeholders all along the chain of recorded music.