Absolutely not.
First, if we want to talk about the macroeconomic impact of the carbon tax, the government's own data show it's costing Canadians $11.9 billion this year. That's $295 going out of the economy for every Canadian.
If you look at every individual who is forced to pay this carbon tax on everything they purchase, I certainly think it's not good for Canadians as a whole. I think about my mother-in-law, who lives in a small community in rural Newfoundland. She has to commute 43 kilometres a day each way for work. She has no public transit. There's no electric public transit available. There are no electric charging stations. She has no other choice but to incur the carbon tax day in and day out just to get to work.
I absolutely disagree that it's providing benefit for Canadian taxpayers.