We receive only the information that they disclose. It's not like a court, which receives the information in confidence and assesses whether the blacked-out information was properly blacked out or not. We have no reason to believe they were inappropriately withholding information that was found somewhere else and not just in a cabinet confidence. We take them at their word that this information was in a cabinet confidence.
However, it's a choice of the government to have the information housed only there. What we're saying is, in the spirit of transparency, make more information publicly available to us and essentially revisit the choice as to where information that's important for Canadians in terms of accountability is housed.
We aren't saying that the information was improperly redacted or anything like that. We're saying that the choice that was made to have it only in the cabinet confidence and nowhere else reduces the transparency and accountability. That's why recommendation 6.84 is in there; and it's been agreed to.