Good afternoon. Thank you to the committee for this opportunity to share the perspective of Environmental Defence.
My name is Julia Levin. I'm the associate director of our national climate program.
Environmental Defence is concerned about the significant amount of public funds being earmarked for carbon capture and storage, as well as how the Pathways project is being used to greenwash the Pacific link pipeline and expanded oil and gas production.
Despite decades of research and development, CCS remains expensive and energy-intensive, with limited potential to deliver significant cost-effective emissions reductions at scale. CCS over-promises and underdelivers. The vast majority of planned CCS projects, both around the world and here at home, never make it off the ground. Those that do struggle to meet their promised targets.
In Canada, there are fewer than 10 commercial CCS projects currently operating, and they capture only 0.05% of national emissions. Global carbon capture capacity stands at around 50 million tonnes of CO2 per year, less than 0.1% of annual global carbon emissions, which is a number that has barely increased over the last decade.
Most carbon capture is used for enhanced oil recovery to reach oil deposits that otherwise would not have been recoverable. This is not a climate strategy. It's an oil production strategy. More oil production means more wildfires, droughts and floods, which in turn means worse health outcomes for Canadians, uninsurable homes and higher food prices.
Despite this, the Government of Canada is now in the process of expanding the CCUS investment tax credit to include enhanced oil recovery—or EOR—projects. When the tax credit was first introduced despite the objections of over 400 of Canada's leading experts, the government defended it by insisting it would not be used for EOR. The Prime Minister has since reversed that promise, and Canada will now be subsidizing oil production, a violation of the country's inefficient fossil fuel guidelines, as even government officials admit.
We are especially concerned about the enormous amounts of public funds that are being promised to the Pathways CCS project. Pathways is being proposed by the Oil Sands Alliance, which represents five of the largest oil sands companies operating in Canada. It would require more than 650 kilometres of high-pressure CO2 pipelines to move captured carbon from various oil sands facilities to an underground storage hub near Cold Lake, Alberta.
The Oil Sands Alliance has stated that the Pathways CCS project could cost up to $30 billion to build, a large increase from previous estimates. Canadian and Albertan taxpayers are already on the hook to pay a significant portion of that, up to $20 billion. Oil Sands Alliance companies could pay most of those costs with their profits from just one quarter, given the windfall profits they are earning this year.
Nonetheless, oil and gas companies keep asking for larger handouts. Clearly, all of their lobbying is paying off, given that the government has said that they will also cover the project's ongoing operational costs. This could cost Canadians up to another $1 billion per year for the lifespan of these projects.
At the same time, the project's promised emissions reductions have dropped significantly. Initially, the companies involved said that the project would cut 10 megatonnes to 12 megatonnes of CO2 per year by 2030 and up to 40 megatonnes a year by 2050. Now, they're saying it will only capture six megatonnes per year and only starting in 2035. Even if Pathways achieves its target, which is unlikely given the track record of these projects, that's a meagre 6% of oil sands emissions and only 3% of the sector's entire emissions. For context, the Pacific link pipeline, which CCS Pathways is being used to greenwash, would itself lead to nearly 30 megatonnes of additional greenhouse gas pollution.
Meanwhile, on the ground, communities in Alberta are frightened about this project's safety and health hazards, which have largely been overlooked by decision-makers. Through the No to CO2 coalition, many of the affected community members, including landowners, farmers and indigenous groups, have been raising concerns about pipeline safety, groundwater, indigenous rights and emergency preparedness. I know they'd be very happy to speak to the committee on this issue as well and bring that local perspective.
In closing, I'll note that Canada is lagging behind in the global clean electricity transition. The key elements of the energy transition include transition off fossil fuels; scaling up renewable energy and storage options; direct electrification of transportation, homes and industry; and significant improvements in energy efficiency.
Cost-effective, proven and reliable solutions are readily available today for large-scale deployment. These technologies aren't just climate solutions. They are also solutions that are more affordable, reliable and secure for Canadians. While our peers around the world are moving in that direction, this government's decisions are keeping Canada locked on a sunsetting industry. Unless we change direction, Canadians will continue to get left behind, and Canadians will pay the price.
Once again, thank you for this opportunity. I look forward to your questions.