Evidence of meeting #51 for Environment and Sustainable Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was projects.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Levasseur  Environmental Engineering Professor, Université du Québec, As an Individual
Whittingham  Principal, Advance Climate Solutions
Merchant  Executive Director, Carbon Removal Canada
Rainville  Vice-President, Central Canada, Clean Prosperity
McElhone  Research Manager, Clean Prosperity
Levin  Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada
O'Reilly  Chief Operating Officer, International CCS Knowledge Centre

4:25 p.m.

Principal, Advance Climate Solutions

Ed Whittingham

No, I don't receive any funding from the federal government. I have clients who hire me to provide them with advisory services. We have, as a member, the Advance carbon removal coalition, which is supported both by philanthropy and member fees. Each member pays a nominal amount to be part of it. Then there are some philanthropic foundations that support my work too.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Greg McLean Conservative Calgary Centre, AB

Thank you. Congratulations on those clients.

Tell me about the $10 million and how you think the government's prepurchasing is going to lead to 10 times as much investment in carbon removal in Canada as the government's invested, because I think that's a bit of a speculation. I'd like to see that land. If you can give us more illustration of that, I think the committee would appreciate it.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Give a short answer, please, as the member's time is up.

Go ahead, Mr. Whittingham.

4:25 p.m.

Principal, Advance Climate Solutions

Ed Whittingham

In simple math, the feds committed $10 million, and then we brought in a whole bunch of companies to commit to a total target of $100 million. That's the 10 times number.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much.

Lastly, we will turn to Mr. Greaves online for five minutes.

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair, and good afternoon, colleagues. Thank you to our witnesses for joining us.

I'd like to stay with Mr. Whittingham for my first question.

Thank you for joining us, sir.

I think we can hear, coming from some of our colleagues' questions, shades of how previous climate change policies initiated during the last 11 years have had some of the empirical basis undermined and questioned. I'd really like to give you the chance, Mr. Whittingham, to elaborate on the economic benefits that you see associated with carbon removal. You've said on the record that carbon removal is one of the greatest economic opportunities that Canada has. You've been very positive today.

Can you put a little more colour on how you see those benefits being generated and, in particular, whether you see carbon removal technologies as offering more dispersed benefits to communities across the country rather than perhaps being as heavily concentrated in a single location, as certain CCUS projects would lead us to expect?

4:30 p.m.

Principal, Advance Climate Solutions

Ed Whittingham

I'm happy to, Mr. Greaves.

I'll go back to the Thetford Mines example because I think it's particularly exciting, and that's part of the reason that the local community is so supportive of it. It fits in with the initiative DuGrisAuVert, which is looking at what you do with these mine tailings sitting on the landscape that now are, in effect, environmental insults, and how you turn them from a negative to a positive.

From the modelling that Stripe has generated.... Again, Stripe and Frontier have a $132-million offtake announcement that's hanging in the wings. It's waiting in the wings if we can get a positive indication on the carbon mineralization ITC. From the numbers that we've run, for about $140 million of avoided tax revenue—that's the cost to the government—it's going to generate $14 billion in investment in that area alone in carbon mineralization.

While it's not a trillion dollars, and I know the federal government—I joke—doesn't get out of bed unless it's $100 billion these days, that's still not chump change, especially in an industry that's still young, with lots of growth potential.

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Thank you for that additional detail.

Turning to you, Mr. Merchant, I'll say that it's good to see you again. Thank you for joining us today. In your opening remarks, you said something that caught my attention. There are two particular pieces I'd like to flag.

The first is a very succinct summary of the importance of carbon removal technologies as essentially being the net in net zero. That is really a useful tool for people to understand both sides of the accounting ledger, so to speak, and both sides of the carbon ledger that goes into the broad discussions around net zero, which of course is the climate target that Canada remains committed to.

The other comment you made that got my attention as the member of Parliament for Victoria, representing an island and a coastal community, was on the opportunities for marine-based carbon removal. I'd love to ask you to expand on that point. What opportunities do you see that are specifically related to the marine environment and coastal communities in this country?

October 22nd, 2026 / 4:30 p.m.

Executive Director, Carbon Removal Canada

Na'im Merchant

Canada leads the world right now in innovation and research around marine carbon removal, that is, helping the ocean accelerate its natural process of removing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

The ocean is the largest carbon sink in the world right now, and there are companies that are enabling it by adding alkalinity to rivers or ocean areas at small scale. They are seeing that it reduces the acidity of those marine environments. In rivers, it can bring back salmon habitats. It's been used for decades to counter the impact of acid rain on our rivers, and it turns out that it removes CO2 from the atmosphere.

As a country with more lakes, rivers and ocean coastline than anywhere else in the world, this is an area in which we should be leading in British Columbia and in Atlantic Canada.

While we're doing a lot of innovative research and development in this area, we need to do larger demonstrations. We need to make sure that companies have regulatory sandboxes to do larger demonstrations of this really promising technology that can do carbon removal at large scale and low cost and that can de-acidify marine environments across the country.

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Yes. Thank you for that.

One thing I have encountered in this role that is related to marine carbon storage is the cobenefit potential that exists for marine, riverine and coastal ecosystems. I'm wondering if you could speak to what I understand are some of the cobenefits that natural carbon storage solutions offer, particularly in tidal regions, to help the government and local communities meet other important goals related to conservation, ecological restoration and so forth.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Give a short answer, please, as we're out of time.

4:30 p.m.

Executive Director, Carbon Removal Canada

Na'im Merchant

I'll say that some of the demonstration funding should go toward proving out those cobenefits, because those are really important. They matter to the community, and we should be putting money toward making sure that we can verify those ecological and community benefits. That's part of the demonstration funding we've been advocating for.

Will Greaves Liberal Victoria, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much.

Thank you very much to all of our witnesses. That concludes our time with you this afternoon.

We will suspend briefly to switch to the next set of witnesses.

Thanks, everybody.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Okay, everybody. Can we get started with our second hour of witness testimony for the carbon capture and underground storage study that we're kicking off today?

Thank you to our witnesses for joining us to share your insights.

Today, we have with us Etienne Rainville, vice-president for central Canada of Clean Prosperity, along with Chloe McElhone, research manager.

Welcome, both of you.

We also have, online, Julia Levin, associate director, national climate, from Environmental Defence Canada.

Welcome, Julia.

In person, we have Breanne O'Reilly, chief operating officer of the International CCS Knowledge Centre.

Thank you. We look forward to hearing from you.

Each organization will have five minutes to give some opening remarks, and then we'll turn to members' questions. I do have a little reminder for when your time is up, should you need it. We'll try to have a good, efficient hour.

I will begin with Mr. Rainville.

The floor is yours for five minutes, please.

Etienne Rainville Vice-President, Central Canada, Clean Prosperity

Madam Chair and members of the committee, thank you very much for the invitation to appear today.

My name is Etienne Rainville. I'm the vice-president, central Canada, at Clean Prosperity, a non-partisan, not-for-profit climate policy organization focused on market-driven solutions that reduce emissions and grow Canada's low-carbon economy. I'm joined by my colleague Chloe McElhone, our research manager, who will be providing our remarks.

Chloe McElhone Research Manager, Clean Prosperity

Thank you, Etienne.

Thank you, Madam Chair and members of the committee, for having us here today.

Carbon capture utilization and storage represents a significant opportunity for Canada to attract low-carbon investment while also decarbonizing industry. This is an opportunity that Canada is uniquely positioned for because of both—

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

I'm sorry. We need to pause for one moment. I hear we don't have interpretation. I will pause your time.

Are we okay?

I'm sorry. Go ahead.

4:40 p.m.

Research Manager, Clean Prosperity

Chloe McElhone

This is an opportunity that Canada is uniquely positioned for due to both its ample underground storage potential and a regulatory framework that's poised to incentivize projects. However, that advantage is not guaranteed. Other countries are competing to attract the same investments, and Canadian projects are stalling at final investment decisions.

Canada is already a world leader in CCUS, with significant facilities and infrastructure already in operation today. Those include Entropy's Glacier, Shell's Quest, Nutrien's Redwater, the Sturgeon Refinery—all of these are in Alberta—and SaskPower's Boundary Dam. There are more under construction in Alberta, including Enhance Energy's sequestration hub and Dow's Path2Zero project.

The most common technology in Canada to date is point-source capture: removing emissions before they reach the atmosphere by way of permanent underground storage or for use in other processes, such as enhanced oil recovery. Today, Canada has almost four million tonnes of annual capture capacity from point-source projects. The technology is proven, and existing projects show that the real bottleneck is economic.

For many industries in Canada, carbon capture is one of the only paths to deep emissions reductions. In 2024, Canada's large industrial facilities reported over 30 million tonnes of process emissions. These are emissions coming from chemical reactions rather than burning fuel, which means they can't be eliminated through switching out fossil fuels or through electrification. These make up about two-thirds of emissions in the cement sector and more than a third in fertilizer and other chemical industries. Even in sectors in which fuel switching and efficiency options exist, carbon capture is often among the most cost-effective ways to reduce emissions on a per-tonne basis.

Canada has built strong capital support for carbon capture, and projects need this. The federal investment tax credit covers half the cost of capture equipment, and Alberta adds an additional 12% grant.

What holds up investments?

Well, carbon capture projects are unique when you compare them with most other low-carbon investments. A wind farm sells electricity, and an energy-efficiency project helps pay for itself through reduced fuel costs. A carbon capture project only has one benefit: reducing or avoiding a tonne's worth of carbon emissions. That tonne has no value unless policy gives it one. In Canada, the policy that pays for those emissions and those tonnes being captured year after year is industrial carbon pricing. Every tonne that a facility captures either lowers its compliance costs with respect to regulation or earns a credit it can sell.

In theory, that's exactly the incentive a carbon capture project needs. In practice, three things get in the way of relying on that revenue. First, carbon credits trade at a discount to the headline carbon price. Second, the carbon price rises slowly, reaching $140 by 2040. Lastly, carbon capture projects are large capital expenditures that run upwards of 20 years and beyond, so ongoing revenue needs certainty over a long time frame.

The recent memorandum of understanding with Alberta provides clear support for this in the form of an effective minimum credit price of $130 by 2040. Our modelling suggests that, today, the average carbon capture project needs around $120 per tonne after taking into account those capital incentives. At $130, many projects can reach viability, although inflation will take a bite out of that every year. This is in line with the U.S.'s 45Q tax credit, which pays about $115 Canadian per tonne stored from day one. That said, it's important to reach a strong credit price as soon as possible. Every year that it takes to reach $130 is another year of uncertainty. Carbon contracts for difference can help bridge that gap by locking in the future value of credits today.

Carbon pricing isn't the only source of ongoing support. Oil and gas accounts for about 30% of Canada's national emissions. When those facilities capture carbon, they lower the carbon intensity of their fuels and can earn credits under the clean fuel regulations, adding an important layer of second operating revenue to these projects.

None of this is to say that capital support doesn't matter, because it does. However, ongoing revenue is essential to get carbon capture projects built and to keep them running. If we get that right, Canada can turn this opportunity into a reality.

Thank you. We look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much to both of you.

We will now turn to Ms. Levin for five minutes.

The floor is yours.

Julia Levin Associate Director, National Climate, Environmental Defence Canada

Good afternoon. Thank you to the committee for this opportunity to share the perspective of Environmental Defence.

My name is Julia Levin. I'm the associate director of our national climate program.

Environmental Defence is concerned about the significant amount of public funds being earmarked for carbon capture and storage, as well as how the Pathways project is being used to greenwash the Pacific link pipeline and expanded oil and gas production.

Despite decades of research and development, CCS remains expensive and energy-intensive, with limited potential to deliver significant cost-effective emissions reductions at scale. CCS over-promises and underdelivers. The vast majority of planned CCS projects, both around the world and here at home, never make it off the ground. Those that do struggle to meet their promised targets.

In Canada, there are fewer than 10 commercial CCS projects currently operating, and they capture only 0.05% of national emissions. Global carbon capture capacity stands at around 50 million tonnes of CO2 per year, less than 0.1% of annual global carbon emissions, which is a number that has barely increased over the last decade.

Most carbon capture is used for enhanced oil recovery to reach oil deposits that otherwise would not have been recoverable. This is not a climate strategy. It's an oil production strategy. More oil production means more wildfires, droughts and floods, which in turn means worse health outcomes for Canadians, uninsurable homes and higher food prices.

Despite this, the Government of Canada is now in the process of expanding the CCUS investment tax credit to include enhanced oil recovery—or EOR—projects. When the tax credit was first introduced despite the objections of over 400 of Canada's leading experts, the government defended it by insisting it would not be used for EOR. The Prime Minister has since reversed that promise, and Canada will now be subsidizing oil production, a violation of the country's inefficient fossil fuel guidelines, as even government officials admit.

We are especially concerned about the enormous amounts of public funds that are being promised to the Pathways CCS project. Pathways is being proposed by the Oil Sands Alliance, which represents five of the largest oil sands companies operating in Canada. It would require more than 650 kilometres of high-pressure CO2 pipelines to move captured carbon from various oil sands facilities to an underground storage hub near Cold Lake, Alberta.

The Oil Sands Alliance has stated that the Pathways CCS project could cost up to $30 billion to build, a large increase from previous estimates. Canadian and Albertan taxpayers are already on the hook to pay a significant portion of that, up to $20 billion. Oil Sands Alliance companies could pay most of those costs with their profits from just one quarter, given the windfall profits they are earning this year.

Nonetheless, oil and gas companies keep asking for larger handouts. Clearly, all of their lobbying is paying off, given that the government has said that they will also cover the project's ongoing operational costs. This could cost Canadians up to another $1 billion per year for the lifespan of these projects.

At the same time, the project's promised emissions reductions have dropped significantly. Initially, the companies involved said that the project would cut 10 megatonnes to 12 megatonnes of CO2 per year by 2030 and up to 40 megatonnes a year by 2050. Now, they're saying it will only capture six megatonnes per year and only starting in 2035. Even if Pathways achieves its target, which is unlikely given the track record of these projects, that's a meagre 6% of oil sands emissions and only 3% of the sector's entire emissions. For context, the Pacific link pipeline, which CCS Pathways is being used to greenwash, would itself lead to nearly 30 megatonnes of additional greenhouse gas pollution.

Meanwhile, on the ground, communities in Alberta are frightened about this project's safety and health hazards, which have largely been overlooked by decision-makers. Through the No to CO2 coalition, many of the affected community members, including landowners, farmers and indigenous groups, have been raising concerns about pipeline safety, groundwater, indigenous rights and emergency preparedness. I know they'd be very happy to speak to the committee on this issue as well and bring that local perspective.

In closing, I'll note that Canada is lagging behind in the global clean electricity transition. The key elements of the energy transition include transition off fossil fuels; scaling up renewable energy and storage options; direct electrification of transportation, homes and industry; and significant improvements in energy efficiency.

Cost-effective, proven and reliable solutions are readily available today for large-scale deployment. These technologies aren't just climate solutions. They are also solutions that are more affordable, reliable and secure for Canadians. While our peers around the world are moving in that direction, this government's decisions are keeping Canada locked on a sunsetting industry. Unless we change direction, Canadians will continue to get left behind, and Canadians will pay the price.

Once again, thank you for this opportunity. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Ms. Levin.

I'll now turn to Ms. O'Reilly, for five minutes. Thank you.

Breanne O'Reilly Chief Operating Officer, International CCS Knowledge Centre

Thank you, Chair and committee members, for having me today.

I am Breanne O'Reilly, the chief operating officer at The International CCS Knowledge Centre.

The Knowledge Centre exists to de-risk and advance CCUS and engineered removals by technical, strategic and policy support, as well as by sharing lessons learned both domestically and internationally.

Carbon capture is not a universal solution, but it is an important option for meeting our climate ambitions. We know it works. Our challenges are around deploying it economically and reliably at scale.

Canada is a leader in CCUS. We have been demonstrating monitoring and verification of long-term storage at the Weyburn-Midale site in Saskatchewan for over 25 years. Boundary Dam has been capturing and storing CO2 for 12 years, and Quest has been capturing for 11 years. We have also developed substantial transportation infrastructure with the Alberta carbon trunk line, and there are other projects in development or operations across the country.

Canada is internationally recognized for this experience and expertise. Our engineering, subsurface characterization, monitoring, regulatory frameworks and project integration are sought internationally.

There is that value, as well. I recently came back from the Philippines, where I spoke at the ASEAN Energy Business Forum, meeting with government officials and business officials, helping them walk through challenges that Canada has already addressed.

Despite this expertise, it is challenging to deploy new projects for a number of reasons. Capturing the CO2 is the first step in the value chain. We then have to compress, transport, store or use and monitor that CO2. Projects are expensive, long-term investments, and they require coordination and risk management across that entire value chain in order to be commercially deployable.

Just because one technology works in one application, this doesn't mean that it will necessarily work as well in every application. Challenges with integrating into different industrial processes include challenges with CO2 concentration or impurities in the flue gas, energy and water requirements, the footprint needed, transport and storage access, and balancing those capital and operating costs.

Demonstration projects are really important in producing the data to address those challenges and inform future projects. Public investment helps address those barriers. Canada's research and demonstration funding has helped improve technical uncertainties. The CCUS ITCs help address upfront costs. Industrial carbon pricing provides value to avoided emissions. Carbon contracts for difference address uncertainty over time. Infrastructure development and regulatory frameworks support coordination, permitting and long-term certainty. All of these mechanisms complement one another, and no single measure addresses every barrier.

Companies exist to produce the energy materials and products that Canadians depend on. Many are important to Canada's energy security and international competitiveness. CCUS is one tool they can use to reduce emissions and to deliver value. However, investments have to make sense alongside their core business operations, particularly when they compete in global markets.

To support further deployment, we need to maintain predictable investment decisions. These projects operate for decades and require significant capital. Decisions need confidence in the regulations and the economic value of emissions reductions. We need to connect demonstration funding to industrial deployment, supporting demonstrations that identify industrial challenges, generate performance data and create pathways to commercial projects. We need to continue to support coordinated infrastructure development. Shared transportation and storage costs can serve multiple projects and reduce costs dramatically, but they require coordination of investments, capacity and development timelines.

Canada has decades of carbon management experience, and we've already invested substantially in the industry. The opportunity now is to use what we know to support competitive Canadian industries, deliver emissions reductions and create internationally valuable projects and capabilities.

The next phase depends not only on advancing individual projects and technologies but also on making emissions reductions work within the industries and the economics that depend on them.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Ms. O'Reilly.

We'll now turn to questions from members. We'll begin with the Conservative Party and Mr. Leslie for six minutes.

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Branden Leslie Conservative Portage—Lisgar, MB

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'll start with you, Ms. O'Reilly.

Minister Dabrusin was just in China, praising closer environmental co-operation with the CCP government there. Meanwhile, China began construction of another 25 gigawatts of coal power production in the first six months of this year alone. There's no requirement in China to have any sort of carbon capture technology associated with this.

I understand the work that you guys, as an organization, have done. We are well placed, but what do we do about engagements with countries that are clearly producing far more? How do we best go about encouraging the Communist Party in China to take on Canadian technologies like this?