Evidence of meeting #53 for Environment and Sustainable Development in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.)

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Keith  Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual
Zitner  General Manager, Carbon to Sea Canada
Jarvis  Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.
Lawton  Emeritus Professor, Carbon Management Canada
Kravtsov  Chief Executive Officer, CarbonCure Technologies Inc.
Philip  Vice-President, Community and Government Relations, Planetary Technologies

October 29th, 2026 / 4 p.m.

Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.

Alastair Jarvis

We capture CO2 from biomass flue gas, react it with seawater and limestone in a closed engineered system and store the result as dissolved bicarbonate in the ocean. Bicarbonate is already the main form that carbon takes in seawater, and we know it stays there for thousands of years. The water that we return carries extra bicarbonate, which is what gives seawater its buffering capacity.

At scale, the effect is tiny, and it isn't something we claim or sell.

I'm tempted to go back to the biomass question in terms of sustainability. Let me start there.

The federal forest sector transformation task force put the problem pretty plainly in the spring, when they said, “No industry player can be profitable using only 30% of a tree.” In Nova Scotia, where I live, when the Bowater mill in Liverpool closed, the low-grade wood lost its market, and that hit sawmills in rural communities pretty hard. Getting more value from every stem cut is what pays for more careful, more expensive forest management.

Under the Isometric standard that we sell under, sustainable sourcing is a yes-or-no test in our supply chain. Feedstock either meets the sustainability criteria audited back to the forest that it came from or generates no credits at all.

I want to be clear. We don't make any carbon claims in the forest for improved forest management. What we pay for is sustainability assurance, which buyers require before they'll accept the removal that we claim at the stack.

I don't know if I have time, but I will answer some of the questions about the work we're doing.

4 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

You have about 20 seconds.

4 p.m.

Vice-President, External Affairs, pHathom Technologies Inc.

Alastair Jarvis

I'll leave it there.

I can also talk about what we're doing at the Huntsman Marine Science Centre around ecotoxicology testing, but I'll leave it there for now.

4 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you, Mr. Watchorn.

Mr. Bonin, you have the floor for six minutes.

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Mr. Keith, I'd like to discuss a carbon capture and sequestration project, the Pathways Plus project.

Do you think this justifies the increase in gas, oil or oil sands production, as the Prime Minister wants to do?

4 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I'm sorry. I'm guessing you said, “justify the production of additional oil and gas”. Is that correct?

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

Yes, that's correct.

4:05 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

That's a reasonable fear, but in practice, I think not.

Canada is a small part of the global oil market. There are good reasons that we expect the oil market to peak relatively soon. Those reasons are, most importantly, electric vehicles, but there are other shifts in oil and gas. I think that will be what determines the long-term oil price and, therefore, what happens in Canada.

In the long run, if we want a stable climate, we are obviously going to have to move away from oil and gas and bring its production down toward zero. I think that will be driven by larger market forces and collective decisions that are made about decarbonization.

On this idea of capturing the upstream CO2 from that project, the reason I would not choose to put much effort into that is that our goal as Canadians is to do two things. It's to reduce our own emissions and also to build technologies and companies that can provide value added to the Canadian economy to manage another challenge Canada has, which is relatively low economic productivity growth.

If we develop some technology that is replicable around the world and we can hope to have a sustainable business selling it, that's a plus. I think the problem with the Oil Sands Alliance Pathways project is it's a type of CCS that's unique to that project. It has very high dollars a tonne, and it's not likely to be replicable in other projects.

I want to use the time, while I have it, to say that several people have mentioned Isometric verification. Be careful. Isometric was funded by Lowercarbon Capital. There's a little ecosystem of things funded together that are not truly independent, and there needs to be a cleaner independent review that I don't believe Isometric provides.

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

In the last budget, the Liberal government changed its policy. It promised not to fund or subsidize carbon capture and sequestration in oil production, but it has changed its mind. It now allows subsidies to produce more oil. It subsidizes carbon sequestration and capture to produce more oil. We're talking about enhanced oil recovery.

Do you think it's a good idea to provide subsidies for this type of project?

4:05 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

No, I don't think it's a good idea.

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

That's very clear.

The government, meaning the Prime Minister, talks about green oil or carbon-free oil when he talks about expansion projects, such as an oil sands pipeline with a million barrels a day capacity. He says it could be green oil or carbon-free oil because of the Pathways Plus project on carbon capture and sequestration.

What are your thoughts on that? Is it greenwashing?

4:05 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

It's complicated. I have both citizenships, but I feel much more Canadian. With the—I'm trying to find a polite way to say it—dangerous, threatening stance of the U.S. government toward Canada, I feel there are good reasons for Canada to look for alternative pathways to export a product. On that basis, I think there are reasons to support the pipeline, even though, in the long run, we will be transitioning away slowly from oil and gas.

What's not clear is whether there's actually a need for it. The existing pipeline can be expanded by at least a few hundred thousand barrels a day, as I understand it, pretty easily. To justify the new pipeline, there would have to be major new investments in increasing production capacity. While I'm not an expert, I am an Albertan and I listen to the oil and gas industry, and it's not clear to me that there's a real, burning interest in doing that. I think that's because it's not obvious that those investments will pay off, given the likely forecast for lower oil and gas prices as we go past peak production.

Overall, I would not vote for that pipeline if there were a referendum, but it's complicated, because there are legitimate reasons that Canada must think very hard about reaching export markets outside the U.S.

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

I think you talked about the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, or IPCC. In the latest IPCC report, there's a graph—I don't know if you've seen it—that compares some renewables in terms of their potential to reduce emissions and costs. If I remember correctly, carbon sequestration and capture, which were compared in this graph, had a much lower potential and a much higher cost than those associated with renewable energy, for example.

Can funding carbon capture and sequestration projects hinder other pathways, such as those supported by renewable energy, which could be more worthwhile?

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Give a short answer, please. We're out of time.

4:10 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

Is the question still for me?

Patrick Bonin Bloc Repentigny, QC

Yes, the question is for you.

4:10 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I'd say that this is partially true, but there's a lot of uncertainty or spinning. There are different interests underneath those cost estimates.

If you're asking about CCS, let's start with the clearest case for CCS. I think that's cement. Cement produces CO2 as process emissions, as opposed to energy input. I forget the exact number now, but it's about 5% of global emissions. Forgive me if I have the wrong number.

The Chair Liberal Shannon Miedema

Thank you very much, Mr. Keith, for that answer.

Thank you, Mr. Bonin.

We'll now turn to Mr. Bexte for five minutes.

4:10 p.m.

Conservative

David Bexte Conservative Bow River, AB

Thank you, Chair.

Thank you, witnesses. It's been a fascinating discussion. At the risk of getting too technical, which I hope we don't, I'm keenly interested in this.

Professor Keith, you spoke a bit about biomass and how there are trade-offs in how we consider it. I'm very interested in how that's related to drawing the lines around arbitrary systems when we're deciding where to measure success. Historically, the government seems to predominantly measure success by how much money they spend on a file, as opposed to results.

How do we get the measurements right so that we can filter out different technologies at an early stage, instead of drifting over to picking winners and losers?

4:10 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I don't know. It's possible that some kind of new institution is needed to do that. I would say that academic institutions don't often do that very well, because they either don't have enough access to the underlying data or don't do that kind of production work. Government institutions often don't do that kind of analysis very well because they also have to justify all sorts of government policy. There aren't clear industrial third parties that do it.

To give us good-quality estimates of what the marginal cost is in dollars per tonne in various government policies.... There are lots of well-intentioned government policies, but they have very different costs in terms of dollars per tonne. We may need some kind of new institution.

I don't think it needs to be very expensive, but we need an institution that could get access to data, including industry data, in some cases, under NDAs, the way a big accounting firm works. It could produce high-quality, open estimates of what the costs are—a kind of dashboard, if you like. It wouldn't be something to set the policy but rather something to give information on what the current costs are. Canada doesn't have a mechanism to do that.

4:10 p.m.

Conservative

David Bexte Conservative Bow River, AB

You mentioned earlier that you have ideas on how to design verification pathways. Is this what you're getting at?

4:10 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

No, that's a separate topic.

To me, the question I thought I was answering was this: In the current economy, what's the cost of, say, heat pumps versus solar subsidies versus transportation subsidies versus nuclear power?

4:10 p.m.

Conservative

David Bexte Conservative Bow River, AB

It's not necessarily about emissions management. The scope of this study is carbon capture, utilization and storage. It's related. It's in the whole basket of what you're talking about. It's about specifically choosing types of technologies and the size of footprint on the environment they should have as an effect that should be evaluated. If you arbitrarily draw a boundary around a technology, yet the adjacent supportive industry, technology or resource has a big impact on that—

4:10 p.m.

Professor, Geophysical Sciences, University of Chicago, As an Individual

David Keith

I think I understand you better.

4:10 p.m.

Conservative

David Bexte Conservative Bow River, AB

We have to get the boundaries right. There's a lot of manipulation in order to jury-rig or engineer outcomes. This is something I'm concerned about. I know I'm going on about this a lot, but I'm trying to set the stage. It relates to how credits and verification issues emerge to support that picking-and-losing process. Objectivity is what we need.