Well, we gave you our policy advice in the presentation. Jean-Jacques Rousseau once said, “I'm here to discuss principles. I will not dispute the facts.”
I'm not an expert. I believe that Parliament--it doesn't matter if I believe it or not--is sovereign, and if an act of Parliament is crafted, with whatever flaws are in it, it still has to be obeyed. Of course, there's a role for the courts in interpreting that, but our default is to trust the servant of Parliament, the Information Commissioner, that the CBC should be required to allow the Information Commissioner to look at material in confidence. Then the dispute should happen based on the decision of the Information Commissioner.