I've heard some very reasonable concerns. For example, if you're only going to provide public access to a fraction of 1% of your overall expenditures, then you could simply move your expenditures to a place where your section 68.1 exemption would apply. You could move your hospitality spending under a new column—call it programming, call it creative, call it journalistic—and now all of a sudden you don't have to provide that access to information, or that transparency that is the intent of the act.
For example, it's difficult to understand why CBC didn't publicly release the request that came in on your vehicle fleet. In fact it's impossible to understand why or how, under those three categories of protection, you didn't publicly release this. I think that any reasonable person would have to conclude that if the Information Commissioner had been provided these documents she would have released this information. I think that's why CBC has released it. You didn't have grounds not to release this request.