The crux of the dispute between CBC and the Information Commissioner is section 68.1. Do you not believe that the Information Commissioner is smart enough and talented enough and knowledgeable enough to make a determination as to whether an information request is or is not covered under section 68.1?
It seems to me that the CBC's argument is that “we know what's covered under section 68.1, nobody else knows what's covered under 68.1, and if we say it's covered, then too bad”. Do you not believe or not that the Information Commissioner is smart enough to figure out and make a determination, in an initial review of an access to information request, whether or not it's covered under section 68.1?