Thank you, Chair, and thanks to all of our witnesses this morning. It has been very enlightening.
While there seems to be general agreement that eventually harmonized legislation, regulation and policy development across the democracies may be a counter to surveillance capitalism, that doesn't seem likely any time soon.
Ms. Zuboff, last night you said that the “front line” in surveillance capitalism is Toronto, in Sidewalk Labs and the smart city project.
Mr. Balsillie, you've been quoted as saying that Sidewalk Labs is “a colonizing experiment in surveillance capitalism” and that Sidewalk Labs “continues to weaponize ambiguity”.
For the two of you, perhaps Ms. Zuboff first and then Mr. Balsillie, has the City of Toronto been steamrollered—bamboozled—by Sidewalk Labs' razzle-dazzle, Mr. Doctoroff's vision, as it has gradually emerged?