Evidence of meeting #55 for Access to Information, Privacy and Ethics in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was companies.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

von Finckenstein  Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner
Aquilino  Legal Counsel, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner
DeMoor  Director, Advisory and Compliance, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

5:50 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

It's not been, so far.... In the law, you have the concept of reasonable, which is the man on the street's reaction. It's less than that. There has to be a scintilla of evidence. I like to use that word. It's something that really doesn't sit right, and it warrants doing it.

It's hard to define it, really. It depends on the.... That's one of the reasons why I have been appointed. It's to use my judgment and my experience to do that. If you look at the requirements for my appointment, they suggest I should be a former judge, which I actually am, because judges are used to dealing with these things that are not absolutely defined. The notion is there and you have to apply it in a meaningful and just way.

If I just went ahead and said, “Oh, this is going to start an investigation,” people would undoubtedly bring judicial reviews right away. You may be aware of the recent court case by the Supreme Court that said every decision I make is subject to judicial review—

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Thank you, Commissioner—

5:55 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

It would ask on what basis I launched that investigation: “There's no evidence of that,” “This isn't justice,” etc. I'd be devastated by the court.

5:55 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

All right.

Mr. Thériault, you have the floor for six minutes.

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Commissioner, you said earlier that it would be unreasonable to ask a public office holder—I assume that you weren't necessarily referring to the Prime Minister—to sell their shares or stock options. I can understand that different requirements may apply, depending on the position held and the number of supervisors involved, when it comes to managing potential conflicts of interest and objective risks.

However, let's talk about the position of prime minister. Do you really consider it unreasonable, when a person wants to become prime minister, to require this person to sell their shares and stock options, given that, from an objective standpoint, this person is surrounded by potential conflicts of interest and objective risks? I'm just thinking of Brookfield. I don't know how many people, among the individuals currently under your management, have such a long list of companies whose representatives they can't meet with.

Is this an absolute position? From an ethical perspective, what justifies this standpoint that the prime minister's position is incompatible with objective risks? Don't you think that, from an ethical perspective, the prime minister's position should be incompatible with objective risks, especially in the case of this prime minister? The evidence shows that we've been discussing this for two hours and that we could go on even longer. The rules make the time limited. Do you really believe that the prime minister's position is compatible with his objective situation and with all the conflicts of interest surrounding him?

5:55 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

This isn't my opinion, but rather what the legislation requires. The legislation specifically states that you have the choice to either sell all your assets or place them in a trust.

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

I'm asking for your opinion because we have actually recommended that anyone seeking this position be required to sell their shares and stock options. This applies in particular to a situation where the individual—as is the case with the current prime minister—remains surrounded by conflicts of interest, objective risks of conflicts of interest or even apparent conflicts of interest. You consider this concept quite important.

5:55 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

As legislators, you can, if you wish, make a change or amendment to the legislation. The risk lies in the fact that highly experienced individuals will say that the price is too high and that they won't accept it. You can decide. On the one hand, as you say, this guarantees a conflict. On the other hand, highly experienced and competent individuals may not accept the position because the price is too high.

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

This doesn't necessarily mean that, for the position of prime minister, someone who isn't objectively surrounded by potential conflicts of interest would do a worse job than someone deemed, at first glance, highly competent. A commissioner must take this stance.

Currently, the only people responsible for applying the conflict of interest screen are subordinates. Now, let's talk about what those subordinates told us, Commissioner. This actually led to a conversation that we had, and I'll remind you of it. When they came to see us, they said that they had a great deal of contact with you and that they consulted with you almost every day. We had the impression that you were part of the team. During the first meeting, I even asked whether you should have a department to oversee the management of this conflict of interest screen. You told me that you didn't want to serve as judge and jury.

These two men came to meet with us. They told us that they were in constant contact with the Office of the Commissioner. I thought that I would ask the commissioner if he felt as though he were serving as judge and jury.

You told me earlier that it was every three months.

I would like to know exactly who is telling the truth here.

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

Every three months, we have a set meeting. It's on my schedule. Of course, we have other interactions between these quarterly meetings. It depends on the situation. It's quite difficult to manage the screen. Some situations arise that no one has considered and that haven't happened before. Of course, we discuss these matters, and I give them my opinion. They can accept it or not. It's their choice. My job is simply to help them.

Luc Thériault Bloc Montcalm, QC

That's why I consider the position of prime minister incompatible with the Prime Minister's current situation and why it poses a real and objective problem in terms of managing that situation. You're showing this today.

6 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative John Brassard

Thank you, Mr. Thériault.

Thank you, Commissioner.

Mr. Cooper, you have five minutes. Go ahead.

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Commissioner, in your opening statement, you indicated that you receive reports from the administrators of the screen, Mr. Sabia and Mr. Blanchard, when the screen is used. So that I understand how that is working.... I presume you receive reports every time the screen is invoked or, in other words, a determination is made that the Prime Minister has a conflict.

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

I probably misspoke. I meant I get the same report that you receive here every three months on the application. I get a copy of that too. That's what I get.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

The Prime Minister's Office and the PCO told us that every time a potential conflict is flagged involving the Prime Minister, an analysis is done and, for the purpose of transparency, a two-page analysis is documented. At the end of the analysis, a decision is made in which the Prime Minister's chief of staff and top adviser sign off to say, “Yes, there's a conflict,” or “No, there's not a conflict.”

Are you not receiving any of those records?

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

That's an internal procedure. I have nothing to do with it.

6 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

You're totally in the dark every time there is a conflict or a potential conflict involving the Prime Minister.

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

That's overstating it. They may have consulted me about it, and I may have explained the situation. I may have given them...but what they did—

6 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

Where is the transparency, sir?

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

What they did was—

6 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

Where is the transparency? They say it's for the purposes of transparency and accountability, yet those records aren't released to the public. The Liberals on this committee have blocked them from this committee, and you're not receiving them.

You said in your 2023-24 report that transparency is a pillar of all conflict of interest regimes. How do you square that statement with zero transparency involving the administration of this screen?

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

I haven't made it clear what my role is. My role is to help them and to aid. They then produce it. They have chosen the process that you described. They have chosen to not make it transparent. It has nothing to do with me. I can't force them to make it transparent. This is their decision.

What they—

6 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

Commissioner—through you, Mr. Chair—you said in answer to a question posed by Mr. Al Soud that the screen is working fine. You have confidence that it is being invoked appropriately and that the Prime Minister is not making decisions where he has a conflict of interest.

How can you say that with any confidence when you're completely in the dark about when the screen is being invoked and when the screen is not being invoked?

6 p.m.

Commissioner, Office of the Conflict of Interest and Ethics Commissioner

Konrad von Finckenstein

I have no reason to doubt that it isn't. I know that—

6 p.m.

Conservative

Michael Cooper Conservative St. Albert—Sturgeon River, AB

It's pure speculation on your part.