First of all, let me say I don't have a different formula. I'm not here advocating anything. All I want to say is that Bill C-52 goes well beyond O'Brien. The O'Brien formula is part of it, but there are three formulas at work in the proposals in clause 80 of Bill C-52. O'Brien did not recommend the continuation of the status quo. O'Brien did not recommend a formula in which there's zero inclusion of natural resource revenues, and yet these are all parts of the proposals.
O'Brien had nothing to say about the offshore accords, and yet there are major changes in the language of the offshore accords, in how calculations will be made. That was not part of O'Brien. So I don't think we can hide behind O'Brien.