The only point I want to make is that the concern we all have here is about giving the minister such broad, unfettered discretion. In our view it's not acceptable. The minister should be accountable to Parliament. There should be pre-publication, pre-debate, be it an instruction or a regulation. That's the point here--nothing more, nothing less. When you give the ministers unfettered discretion in immigration, we've seen in the past that it's been abused in many different circumstances. Obviously we have a concern about that.
