My understanding of tax policy is that taxes are not just intended to get money for the government. There's a second part to tax policy, and that is to influence the behaviour of people. We do that all the time. We use tax policy to encourage people to go to remote areas, or we use tax policy to discourage people from polluting. I think that perhaps the purpose of taxes is much broader than that.
I agree with you; I think services should be fairly remunerated. The reality is that they are not. In the real world, we have to deal with that, and the proposed legislation would have a negative impact on care, whether we like it or not.