I don't find it improper that the Clerk of the Privy Council is the person ultimately responsible for decisions in the public service. In my opinion, that isn't an issue.
I read the evidence that he gave to the committee. My understanding is that the Clerk of the Privy Council is bound by the Access to Information Act and must apply the grounds set out in the act. He also referred to cabinet confidences as a ground for determining the position to take on redactions. That's how I see his role. Personally, I don't see—