Evidence of meeting #39 for Health in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was mental.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Zivojinovic  Journalist, As an Individual
Alexander Caudarella  Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Centre on Substance Use and Addiction
Kennell  Vice-President, Policy, Partnerships and Advancement, Canadian Mental Health Association—National
Smith  Chief Executive Officer, Peel Dufferin Branch, Canadian Mental Health Association
Farihah Ali  Scientist, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, and Principal Investigator, Canadian Research Initiative in Substance Matters, Population and Global Health Institute
Patricia Conrod  Clinical Psychologist and Professor of Psychiatry and Addiction, Centre hospitalier universitaire Sainte-Justine, Université de Montréal, As an Individual

Prof. Patricia Conrod

Quebec has implemented some more restrictive policies around drug regulation that might contribute to protection, and I could tell you more about a couple of them if you'd like to hear it.

Matt Strauss Conservative Kitchener South—Hespeler, ON

Well, I just want to move on. We have such short time.

I think both of you and many of the other previous panellists mentioned this idea of wraparound services, which I take to mean housing with complementary counselling and addiction treatment, and sometimes prescription service.

At a high level, does incarceration not include these things? If I'm incarcerated as a result of criminality related to opioid use disorder, I am given housing. It is also my understanding that addictions treatment, counselling and other rehabilitative services are available in prison. Is that your understanding?

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

You are 15 seconds over, so I am sorry, Dr. Strauss. I have to go to MP Chi for six minutes. Please go ahead.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Thank you, Chair, and thank you to both witnesses for appearing today.

One thing that I think has really become clear throughout this study, especially this session, is that responding to this opioid crisis requires us to look at the whole spectrum and continuum of care, from prevention to helping those who are already struggling with addiction and other mental health challenges. The federal government has made significant federal investments across that spectrum, including a historic $500-million investment in the youth mental health fund, as well as support for community-based services through the substance use and addictions program and emergency treatment fund.

My first question is for Dr. Patricia Conrod.

Dr. Conrod, I think you've touched on this during your opening remarks. Your research is focused on early targeted interventions and preventions and how they can help young people and equip them with the skills that reduce their risk of developing substance use disorders. How important is it that we address youth mental health and substance use prevention together, rather than waiting until young people start developing more serious problems?

Prof. Patricia Conrod

I think it's extremely important, and I think that the evidence supports that approach. It's not a solution for everyone. Therefore, I think we need to maintain supports for young people who are in at-risk situations or who are living with risk factors themselves. They need to be supported with mental health supports at various developmental stages and potentially throughout life.

I will add that one very promising approach to the effective drug and alcohol prevention programs is to partner with integrated youth services and to have integrated youth services be a support to schools as they are implementing evidence-based programs. This is a model that has been developing. We've been partnering in implementing the prevention program with Youth Wellness Hubs Ontario and Foundry. The integrated youth services are now working with schools to implement upstream mental health interventions with school counsellors. They are there to support where needed, and if the brief upstream interventions are not enough for a particular setting or individual, there's more support available. It's a really nice model, I would say.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Thank you so much.

You mentioned the integrated youth services and the hubs, and that's exactly what our government has invested in through the youth mental health fund. There has been a significant amount of investment in expanding community-based youth mental health services.

Again, going back to your research, what would you say are the biggest opportunities to continue making that impact in substance use disorder prevention in young people?

Prof. Patricia Conrod

I think we have clarity on what interventions work, but I would be remiss if I did not discuss the implementation challenges. Delivering in schools is, I believe, the most promising and the best way to deliver equitable mental health and drug prevention, because you can deliver it to a whole grade and everyone will receive it. However, communities are encountering challenges as they're trying to implement at scale. Resources are constrained. There are workforce shortages, and there is staff turnover. We also lack a sustained investment in infrastructure to support preventive mental health. Nobody has taken this on as their primary responsibility.

We need a workforce that's appropriately trained, ideally consisting of members of a professional body who have access to expert supervision and who function within a stepped care approach, as I just described, so that you're going from brief intervention in schools to more intensive mental health and psychosocial supports when needed.

Our experience is that when evidence-based programs really are embedded in how school boards or health authorities work, they are more easily sustained and are more effective. At the moment, however, there is no real sustainable health system to deliver preventive mental health.

Maggie Chi Liberal Don Valley North, ON

Thank you so much, Dr. Conrod.

During your remarks, you were cut off for one minute. I just want to see if you have anything additional to share as part of your opening remarks.

Prof. Patricia Conrod

Thank you very much.

I do want to say that we've published some secondary analyses of the original studies to directly evaluate these middle-school-based interventions targeting young people who are self-reporting psychological risk factors for early onset substance use and related harms. We have identified that we're at the stage in developmental neuroscience where young people can tell you about their level of risk, and we can intervene around that risk using very light-touch, brief cognitive-behavioural interventions.

With respect to prescription opioid use, the evidence is a little less clear. However, one thing we did report recently is that there are solutions to the risk for polysubstance use in high-school-aged students. That is a very robust risk factor for who will go on to develop serious problems with substance use. I think we have a number of very promising programs that just need more systematic investment and support as we attempt to scale these across the country.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you very much.

We will go to Madame Gaudreau for six minutes.

Please go ahead.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Ms. Conrod, can you respond to the question asked by my colleague, Dr. Strauss, regarding the management of drugs and medications in Quebec?

Prof. Patricia Conrod

I would love to, but I'm really not an expert on the topic. I'm much more comfortable talking about the developmental factors involved in substance use disorders. I know that a recently published report shows that opioid prescribing practices in Quebec are currently on the rise. In the past, we saw fewer prescriptions issued. However, these practices are now changing. The trends are heading in a direction that raises concerns.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Is there a correlation between the rise in the suicide rate and the increasing use of opioids?

Prof. Patricia Conrod

I think that I'll need to give you an answer later.

Perhaps, Farihah, you have an answer to this question.

I will have to get back to you, though, with a clear summary of the evidence on that topic.

I can say that programs geared towards young people who show risk factors for substance use disorders protect them from these disorders and from suicidal thoughts. It's quite difficult to demonstrate that suicide can be prevented. It requires large‑scale studies. However, we have already published information showing that suicidal thoughts among young people can be reduced through youth substance use prevention programs.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you.

Ms. Ali, based on your work with people who use drugs, what changes when a person obtains, for example, stable housing or a minimum level of physical security? Does this affect their ability to access care and does it contribute to risk reduction?

12:40 p.m.

Scientist, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, and Principal Investigator, Canadian Research Initiative in Substance Matters, Population and Global Health Institute

Dr. Farihah Ali

Thank you for that question.

Absolutely, I think stable housing and financial security can make an enormous difference in someone's ability to access health care, engage in treatment and reduce substance-related harms. When someone is experiencing homelessness, much of their daily life revolves around meeting basic survival needs, such as finding somewhere to sleep, accessing food, staying safe and sometimes even managing withdrawal. Under those circumstances, attending medical appointments or consistently engaging in treatment becomes much more difficult, and we have the evidence to prove that.

We also know that housing instability can increase exposure to unsafe environments and situations where people may be using drugs alone, for instance, increasing their vulnerability to overdose, and we've seen this in our own research. People who use drugs, whom we interviewed, frequently described housing insecurity, poverty and difficulty accessing these basic resources as barriers to treatment and recovery. When someone has that stable housing and a degree of financial security, they're better positioned to engage with health care and maintain treatment as well as build those supportive relationships.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you.

How can we implement policies—or even programs—to ensure a systemic approach and to give workers the freedom to provide appropriate care to clients who technically vary widely in terms of their processes or challenges? What do we need? We need this in our study report.

12:45 p.m.

Scientist, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, and Principal Investigator, Canadian Research Initiative in Substance Matters, Population and Global Health Institute

Dr. Farihah Ali

That's a really important consideration as well. I think that one of the most important things we can do is move away from a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach and give service providers the flexibility, resources and budget for the individual needs of their clients.

People who use drugs are a very diverse population. Someone experiencing homelessness may need very different supports from someone who has stable housing but, for instance, is struggling with mental health challenges or opioid dependence, and we have seen this again in our own research. Providers frequently describe fragmented funding, restrictive eligibility requirements and limited coordination between services as barriers to delivering this comprehensive care.

I think governments can address this through more flexible and, importantly, sustained funding that allows organizations to really integrate addiction treatment, harm reduction, mental health care and housing support, rather than funding each service in isolation. We also need to involve people with lived and living experience in designing these programs, because they understand where the gaps are.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you, Ms. Ali and Ms. Conrod.

The Chair Liberal Sukh Dhaliwal

Thank you, Madame Gaudreau.

We will go to Mr. Bailey for five minutes.

Please, go ahead.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Thank you, Chair.

I would like to ask both witnesses, Dr. Ali and Dr. Conrod, if wraparound services are available in prison. Could you please, respectfully, give your responses to the clerk, so they can be tabled for this report?

Thank you.

Dr. Conrod, I'm going to go very quickly, because I'm so limited on time.

Are you familiar with CoRE, the Canadian Centre of Recovery Excellence?

Prof. Patricia Conrod

Yes. It's in Alberta.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

They recently did a press release entitled “Research shows overdoses cause irreversible brain injury” that made an “[u]rgent appeal for changes to addiction treatment”.

I'd like you to comment on youth brain development and what you've seen through your research work on the effects of drugs on the brain. Despite this being obvious, the lasting effects on the brain are often mentioned when discussing the opioid crisis, but I think it's important to note for the record and inclusion in this report.

Prof. Patricia Conrod

Thank you for your question. It's an important one.

The evidence in relation to the effects of opioids on brain development is non-existent. It's an area that is most definitely worthy of more research.

Most of the research on the effects of substance use on brain development is limited to alcohol and cannabis use, where both are identified as being associated with neurocognitive developmental risk factors and the potential effects of early-onset substance use on brain development.

With respect to the effects of overdose-related anoxia or exposure to very high levels of highly potent opioids, the evidence is also currently quite limited and worthy of further research.

It's a question I'm very interested in, but there's not a very easy answer to provide you with at the moment. It's very complex research, as you can imagine.

12:50 p.m.

Conservative

Burton Bailey Conservative Red Deer, AB

Thank you for that.

We have tabled this one study. If you have anything else that you'd like to add on that subject, I'm going to ask you to table it.

I'd like to ask you a question. What's more compassionate for kids at risk: programs like the one you've studied, which stop problems early, or handing out high-potency opioids that can get diverted and pull more young people in?

Give a simple answer, please.