What does fiscal responsibility have to do with Bill C-31? We believe fiscal responsibility is about spending taxpayers' dollars wisely. The CCR is committed to an affordable refugee protection system. When money is wasted, it is not available to fund the important task of providing protection. Right now, we understand from Mr. Dykstra that only one percent of refugee claimants actually need to be detained.
Our current system is doing an individualized risk assessment, which works well to protect our society and ensure the integrity of the immigration system. The figure we used was 6%, from CBSA data, which means that 94% of refugee claimants on average do not need to be detained. If this bill passes, we will be detaining 100% of designated arrivals for a year. The math is simple. Ninety-four percent of the people we will be detaining will not need to be detained, if past experience serves us well.
There is no reason to believe that a smuggled refugee claimant is not a genuine refugee. A refugee's mode of arrival tells us nothing about the genuineness of the claim. The UNHCR has repeatedly pointed out that many genuine refugees arrive irregularly and without papers. The reason is obvious: If you're being persecuted by your government, it is hardly likely to give you travel documents or an exit visa to facilitate a visa application to Canada.
The cost of detaining the 94% of claimants who do not need to be detained for that year is huge, if we use the CBSA's figures of $200 a day or $73,000 a year. But if refugee claimants were given work permits and were able to maintain employment and become taxpayers, the cost differential would be enormous.
There's now compelling evidence of the devastating impact of the cost of mandatory detention in Australia. The figures are all in our brief. Look at them. Let's learn from the Australian experiment instead of repeating its mistakes.
And remember, none of these cost estimates take account of the enormous human cost of detention, the impact on the physical and mental health of the detainees, which is severe. Neither do they take into account the future cost of managing these impacts once the refugees are accepted and join our communities as permanent residents. These include documented incidents of—