Evidence of meeting #41 for Citizenship and Immigration in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was needs.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Bezo  President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Bureau for International Education
Dearden  Co-Founder, Roseview Global Incubator Inc.
Duever  Interim Vice-President, Academic and Provost, University of Waterloo
Douglas  Chief Executive Officer, Roseview Global Incubator Inc.
Hirstwood  Director of Business Development, Kingston Economic Development Corporation
Miller  President and Chief Executive Officer, Universities Canada
Grondin  Senior Vice-President, Operations, Comact

4:25 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Bureau for International Education

Larissa Bezo

There have certainly been those conversations. The CBIE has a code of ethical practice that talks about taking a sustainable approach.

We acknowledge that in some communities, with large urban centres as the first instance, there were capacity issues. However, we've also most recently seen a report coming out of Atlantic Canada identifying that there is a talent crisis.

4:25 p.m.

Conservative

Costas Menegakis Conservative Aurora—Oak Ridges—Richmond Hill, ON

Would you say Conestoga is a large urban area? Conestoga College is one of the biggest violators of the international student program.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Mr. Menegakis.

Thank you, Ms. Bezo.

Mr. Joseph, you're up. You have three minutes.

Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair. I know we don't have much time.

Ms. Bezo, let's talk a bit about foreign credential and qualification recognition, which remains a challenge for many professionals. What can the federal government do to facilitate labour market integration, in co-operation with the provinces, for example, Quebec?

4:25 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Canadian Bureau for International Education

Larissa Bezo

There are important opportunities. We're starting to see more of this convening, with our governments at the provincial and municipal levels coming together with the business community and our institutions to look at and define needs. This impacts curriculum planning and pathways, and it impacts planning in terms of global talent that we may wish to attract to come in through our institutions and that could contribute to the labour market.

The alignment piece, from our perspective, is most critical to ensuring that the right stakeholders at the regional and community levels are coming together to have a thoughtful discussion about the specific needs of that community or region.

Natilien Joseph Liberal Longueuil—Saint-Hubert, QC

Thank you, Ms. Bezo.

Mr. Dearden, you highlighted the importance of attracting entrepreneurs to Canada. As someone who is the product of immigration and who has built businesses here, I'd like to hear you talk about the tangible benefits these entrepreneurs bring to Quebeckers and Canadians, particularly in terms of job creation and economic growth.

4:25 p.m.

Co-Founder, Roseview Global Incubator Inc.

Mike Dearden

Thank you very much, and congratulations. You're obviously a very successful entrepreneur in Canada.

We have hundreds of examples of entrepreneurs who have come to this country, created jobs and benefited their communities.

I can think in my own region of someone like Frank Hasenfratz, a fellow who came here from Hungary in the 1950s and built an organization that's worldwide, employs 35,000 people, is proudly Canadian and has been a huge success. There's Peter Munk and Peace by Chocolate. It goes on and on.

Every single one of you in every one of your communities has many stories and knows many people who have built this country. The vast majority of us are immigrants to this country from some point. We may have become entrepreneurs the day we arrived or we may become entrepreneurs in our third or fourth generation, but it is those people who have built our community. I'm sure that even at this table, there are more examples than you, sir, of people who have succeeded as entrepreneurs.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Mr. Joseph.

Thank you, Mr. Dearden.

This concludes our first panel and our first hour.

On behalf of the committee, I want to thank all the witnesses for their time.

Thank you, Professor Duever, for persevering and making sure that we got you on board.

All the testimony was excellent, and it was a great discussion.

We are now going to suspend so that our current group of witnesses can leave. We will resume shortly with the second panel.

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Colleagues, we are beginning the second panel.

I want to give a warm welcome to our witnesses on the panel for the second hour.

As all panellists and committee members know, we are currently studying the attraction and empowerment of global talent to strengthen Canada's economy.

For the second hour, from Comact, we have Simon Grondin, senior vice-president, operations, who's joining us by video conference.

From the Kingston Economic Development Corporation, we have Ms. Shelley Hirstwood, who's the director of business development.

From Universities Canada, we have Gabriel Miller, president and chief executive officer.

A warm welcome to all of you.

Before I ask you to begin your five-minute interventions, I'm going to ask my colleagues to please lower their voices if they're having sidebar conversations.

I will now invite Ms. Hirstwood to begin with her five-minute intervention.

Shelley Hirstwood Director of Business Development, Kingston Economic Development Corporation

Thank you.

Good afternoon, Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for the opportunity to share the perspective of Kingston Economic Development Corporation.

Our organization in Kingston is like many economic development organizations across Canada. We support entrepreneurship, business growth and investment attraction in Kingston, Ontario. We work with local employers—from start-ups to entrepreneurs and small businesses to major multinational manufacturers—and attract international companies to Kingston to set up operations in Canada. Immigration plays a really important role in Kingston's economic growth. Between 2016 and 2021, recent immigrants and non-permanent residents accounted for 31% of our region's population growth. Beyond population growth, immigration helps our business sector access skilled talent, attract investment and support entrepreneurship.

I'd like to begin by recognizing some of the positive work being done by the federal government to support businesses in accessing global talent. Kingston Economic Development is a designated referral partner for IRCC and ESDC through the global talent stream and dedicated service channel. These programs have been valuable tools in supporting businesses and attracting international investment.

We regularly highlight these programs when speaking with foreign companies considering Canada. The ability to access specialized international talent through an efficient and responsive process is a significant competitive advantage. They demonstrate what is possible when immigration policy aligns with businesses and economic development needs. These are Canadian success stories, and we should build on them. However, while these programs work well for certain businesses, many other employers that we work with continue to face challenges in accessing and retaining the talent they need. Today I'd like to highlight three areas in which we believe improvements could make a meaningful difference.

First, businesses need clear, predictable immigration pathways with faster processing times to recruit and retain skilled workers. One of the most significant challenges we hear from employers, day in and day out, is the complexity and the length of the immigration process. Businesses are making investments and planning expansions, yet they lack certainty about their ability to access the talent required. Recently I spoke with a local manufacturer who lost access to employees with very specialized skills when their work permits expired while the extension applications were still being processed. The company was forced to find temporary solutions to maintain operations while waiting for these employees to receive approval and return to work.

This is not an uncommon story. These were skilled workers who were already contributing to our economy. Losing them disrupts operations, reduces productivity and puts at risk the investment the business is making in training. We need faster processing times, simpler applications and greater certainty for employers recruiting and retaining international talent.

Second, immigration programs must better reflect regional industry needs. Labour market requirements vary significantly across Canada. The workforce needs of a manufacturer in Kingston can differ considerably from those of a technology company in Toronto or Vancouver, yet national immigration priorities and occupational classifications do not always reflect these differences. We hear from employers, particularly manufacturers, who struggle to access the talent they need because their occupations don't align with the existing program criteria. Temporary foreign worker restrictions, including workforce caps, can also create additional challenges.

We're also hearing concerns about changes to the open work permits for family members of international students. Kingston is home to Queen's University, St. Lawrence College and the Royal Military College of Canada. We welcome over 40,000 students each year. The city relies on this talent, including the spouses of international students. The current restrictions are having a significant impact on our local employers. We encourage the federal government to work more closely with regional economic development organizations and industry to ensure that immigration programs reflect those local regional needs.

Third, immigration policy represents an opportunity to support business succession and preserve existing Canadian businesses. Canada is facing a significant wave of business ownership transitions. According to the Canadian Federation of Independent Business, 76% of small businesses plan to exit their business within the next 10 years. According to ISED, one in five will be exiting in the next five years. Of these, on average, only 30% of businesses are successfully selling their businesses.

These are established businesses that provide employment and contribute to their communities. Without successful ownership transitions, we risk losing these businesses, jobs, local investment and expertise. International entrepreneurs could play an important role in addressing Canada's growing business succession challenges by acquiring established businesses.

However, from a federal perspective, existing immigration pathways present barriers. The C11 entrepreneurial work permit, for example, provides a temporary work permit for an initial period of up to 18 months, without a direct pathway to permanent residency. This creates uncertainty for entrepreneurs considering the acquisition of an established business, in which a successful ownership transition requires long-term investment, the transfer of institutional knowledge and continuity of operations. The temporary nature of this permit is particularly challenging for entrepreneurs assuming responsibility for existing employees.

This program was not set up for succession. It was set up for investment. There's a real opportunity for Canada to redefine this program to address a very real concern that Canada will be facing with our businesses.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Ms. Hirstwood. You are well over five minutes.

We will go to our next speaker.

Mr. Miller, you have five minutes for your intervention. Go ahead, please.

Gabriel Miller President and Chief Executive Officer, Universities Canada

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Members of the committee, thank you for your invitation today.

Canada has big plans in trade, energy, AI and defence. It's a transformative agenda to strengthen our economy and preserve our way of life, but to deliver, we're going to need talented people. We're going to need leading-edge knowledge. We're going to need new partnerships around the world. Fortunately, our universities can help provide all three.

Universities Canada represents 97 non-profit universities across the country. Our universities educate Canadians, attract talented students and researchers, and connect Canadian businesses with expertise around the world. Their international students are a tremendous asset to our country. They enrich the educational experience, contribute billions of dollars to our economy, create thousands of local jobs and strengthen Canada's trade ties around the world.

The Government of Canada has taken important steps to regain control of our immigration system, but corrections in our international student system have given way to an overcorrection. After reducing the new number of student arrivals by more than 80% since 2023, the country is struggling to attract the international talent it both wants and needs. The federal government must be as serious about achieving its targets for attracting talent as it has been about reducing the number of people entering the country. We need predictable policies, transparent processes and a coordinated effort to restore confidence in the Canada brand. We need a coordinated strategy across immigration, trade, research and workforce priorities, one that is supported by an immigration system that delivers. To get there, we have three recommendations.

First, improve the performance and predictability of our mobility and visa systems. Talent attraction and visa processing are inseparable. Universities can recruit exceptional students and researchers only when qualified applicants receive timely and transparent decisions. Changes to rules and processing timelines make it harder for applicants and institutions to plan. We recommend a phased, risk-informed approach that improves predictability while maintaining program integrity. Let's establish competitive processing standards. Let's publish clear information on approval rates and decision outcomes. Let's communicate policy changes early enough for applicants and institutions to respond.

Second, we recommend supporting targeted bilateral partnerships aligned with Canada's trade and economic priorities. The Canada-India talent and innovation strategy is an excellent example. Similar opportunities exist to deepen partnerships with Europe, including through Erasmus+, but these partnerships depend on reliable mobility pathways that allow students and researchers to move between countries.

Third, we recommend creating a comprehensive international talent, research and innovation strategy. This should bring immigration, trade, research and workforce priorities together across federal departments in collaboration with provinces, territories and institutions. It must include a coordinated international effort to strengthen Canada's reputation and communicate clearly that qualified students and researchers remain welcome here.

The strategy should also recognize linguistic duality and the contribution of francophone international students to our communities.

A coordinated approach will align international recruitment with immigration sustainability, reinforce program integrity and show how international education serves Canada's economic priorities. We are ready to work with government to build an approach that attracts exceptional talent, supports our communities and delivers lasting benefits for Canadians.

Thank you. I would be pleased to answer your questions.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Mr. Miller.

Mr. Grondin for five minutes.

Simon Grondin Senior Vice-President, Operations, Comact

Thank you, everybody, for having me at the committee.

My name is Simon Grondin and I work at Comact. Comact is the largest OEM of sawmill equipment in the world. We're doing all the equipment: from tree handling to lug handling, drying, cutting solutions, dry kilns, planer mills and everything in between, for a complete package.

With our 1,800 employees, we operate across all of North America. We have about 1,000 employees in Canada in different communities. Some of them are in smaller places, such as Saint-Georges and Saint-Éphrem in Beauce county. We also have a smaller facility in Saint-Raymond, outside Quebec City, and some project offices and automation offices in Quebec City and Saguenay. We also have plants in British Columbia, in Vanderhoof and Prince George, and we used to operate in Salmon Arm. We also have plants and offices in different corners of the United States.

What we typically do on our end that differentiates us from other companies is having a high mix and a low volume of products. When we're doing one machine, or two parts or five parts being the same to us, that's the type of volume we're talking about. We have to be very good and flexible at doing these, versus building 10,000 of the similar parts. That creates more complicated automation, and we need to hire trades, as we have very little general labour in our plants. Machinists, welders and millwrights are the types of trades we're looking for at all our sites.

Over the years, we've seen different realities depending on the region we're in. Again, what we've been faced with in immigration lately is that in order for us to grow and sustain our investment—because we invested substantially in Saint-Georges and Saint-Éphrem, Quebec—we went to Colombia to hire machinists, welders and millwrights from this country and integrate them into our own facilities in these trades. Out of the people we have been able to attract so far, with all the different regulations that have happened over the last few years, we've retained only half. Out of this half we're at risk of losing even more. This is combined with the fact that, regionally, these trades are really scarce, and trade schools have decided not to even start a machining program this year. This will put even more pressure on finding these trades locally, which has been very difficult.

There have been different initiatives locally in the region to attract people through the program La Beauce embauche, which was going to different places in Quebec or to French communities in Ontario or New Brunswick. These were initiatives to attract French-speaking people to the province and into our own region, but they had very limited success. That was the first program put together to attract people, but then we still had issues to get people, and we went internationally. Today, this is creating issues in order for us to continue our growth.

At a glance, that's what we've been facing. What we want to look for in the future is how the temporary program could be revised. We don't consider these resources as temporary; they are workers we need in order to continue the course of our business.

I can speak on behalf of my colleagues in the region and in other businesses. We all face similar issues. When we're faced with a global wall-to-wall 10% across the board, or high salary ranges, it really creates issues for us in attracting people.

We would like to discuss that here today.

The Chair Liberal Julie Dzerowicz

Thank you, Mr. Grondin.

I want to thank all the witnesses for their excellent opening statements.

We'll now begin with rounds of questions. Our first round of questions is six minutes each.

We will begin with Ms. Rempel Garner.

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Michelle Rempel Conservative Calgary Nose Hill, AB

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'll start with questions for Mr. Grondin.

My understanding is that your region has an extremely low rate of unemployment. It's somewhere within the 2% to 3% range. Is that correct?

4:55 p.m.

Senior Vice-President, Operations, Comact

Simon Grondin

Yes, it's 2%.

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Michelle Rempel Conservative Calgary Nose Hill, AB

It's well below the rate of natural unemployment.

Would you say that your region has suffered as the federal government has essentially allowed more unskilled workers to enter under the temporary foreign worker program and through the international student program and settle in areas of high unemployment? You've also been sort of painted with the same brush, particularly when it comes to highly skilled labourers like machinists.

4:55 p.m.

Senior Vice-President, Operations, Comact

Simon Grondin

Yes, absolutely. I don't think that for us, in our region, the student issue is something that we're really talking about too much. It's not something that we hear a lot. Definitely, having the overall national immigration problem has created local issues here, as those specific trades in our regions are difficult to find versus having video—

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Michelle Rempel Conservative Calgary Nose Hill, AB

I don't have a lot of time, so I'll briefly ask a couple of questions more.

Would you say that because the government allowed and enabled the abuse of the temporary foreign worker program by companies like Tim Hortons, particularly in areas of high unemployment, highly skilled labourers in regions like yours with very low rates of unemployment, labourers who have integrated into the community, are now...? Essentially, you're now suffering because of poor decisions that were made at a macro level on the TFW program. Would that be a correct assessment?

October 20th, 2026 / 4:55 p.m.

Senior Vice-President, Operations, Comact

Simon Grondin

Yes. Today, we're suffering from the changes, for sure.

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Michelle Rempel Conservative Calgary Nose Hill, AB

Okay. You're saying that perhaps the government needs to be more cognizant of this dynamic as it goes forward and that this would be a recommendation you would make to the committee.

4:55 p.m.

Senior Vice-President, Operations, Comact

Simon Grondin

Absolutely. Also, adding more regionalized—

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Michelle Rempel Conservative Calgary Nose Hill, AB

Thank you. I have a very short period of time, and I have some questions for the other witnesses.

This is for the group from Kingston.

Your area was recently the subject of a W5 documentary, I believe. There was a college mentioned that substantively abused the international student program.

I note that your organization has advocated, as you did today, for more students. Did you do any contingency planning? You're an economic development agency. Did you plan for the removal of that income when the government brought too many people in too fast, or is the strategy now to bring more people back in and keep the levels? Is that what you're telling the committee, especially after that W5 documentary?

4:55 p.m.

Director of Business Development, Kingston Economic Development Corporation

Shelley Hirstwood

We work directly with businesses. Although we work with our post-secondary institutions as well, we do not have a say on their strategies or how they balance their books.