I'd like to commend the prior two presenters for their very excellent and thorough review of those areas of the law. To save this hearing from becoming an echo chamber, I would like to add just to the fringes of their very substantive and well-considered views.
There is a need and a consensus out there that section 67 should be repealed, but it must be done in a manner that is sensitive to the complex cultural, legislative, regulatory, and evolving constitutional context in which first nations operate. This is a very fluid, evolving area of the law and social policy in Canada.
As Ms. Mandell pointed out, with the introduction of the concept of reconciliation and its emergence to the forefront of a framework for addressing Crown-first nations issues, it's important that Bill C-44 be addressed within the principles and context of reconciliation. I think the current draft of the bill, while well-intentioned, doesn't quite meet the mark. A better reconciliation and balance could be achieved.
I'd like to say a broad comment about the act. It really applies to areas of federal jurisdiction, particularly federal governments and federally regulated entities, and for the most part, these tend to be large entities: large corporations and governments, etc. We are now having that act applied to hundreds of first nations governments in very small communities that make decisions on a wide range of matters about rights, entitlements, and membership—who belongs and who is entitled to receive very scarce resources.
First nations governments are challenged, not only with the huge breadth of decision-making, but they're doing so with very limited resources in very challenging circumstances. To apply human rights in this context is absolutely appropriate and necessary, but it must be done in a way that's sensitive to these circumstances.
In my paper, I outline a wide variety of decisions made by first nations governments that may trigger rights issues, whether they're operating under the Indian Act or self-government regimes.
While we believe that the repeal of section 67 is necessary, we believe it must be done in a process sensitive to the principles of reconciliation and the circumstances of first nations. In that regard, we support the recommendations of the Canadian Human Rights Commission and the Canadian Bar Association to the effect that there must be an appropriate consultation process, designed and initiated, that will lead to the development of an appropriate interpretative clause to provide guidance on the application of the act in the context of section 35 rights and the circumstances and governance of first nations.
In that regard, it may be possible to have the repeal enacted but not take effect until an appropriation transition period has enabled the drafting and adoption of an interpretative provision. I would support Mr. Black's view on the nature of what that interpretative provision should look like, so that it provides guidance not only to the commission and tribunal but to first nations and other parties about how this act is to be applied, particularly in first nations communities.
An extensive transition time is important and relevant here for a couple of other reasons. One is that frankly for most first nations this is not on their political radar screen. We act for 20 or 30 first nations. I checked around, and very few knew about this and what its potential implications would be.
Understanding what its implications may be for them, including perhaps a very significant legal review of their current laws, policies, and decision-making practices—and perhaps needing to amend or change those—would be a challenge for many already underresourced communities. They would be vulnerable to all kinds of complaints, given the very scarce resources and numerous decisions they have to make and the relatively poor understanding of how this act would presently play out in relation to their authority in decision-making.
I would really plead for some time and resources to enable first nations to adequately review and ensure that they can address these issues in a proactive way, and to avoid complaints and other matters that may arise. I suggest that this extend over at least two fiscal periods, because it will require that these first nations be provided the resources to address these matters.
The second area is a practical one. Given the number of complaints that will arise in this matter, many first nations simply do not have the resources to deal with complaints—to hire counsel or participate effectively in tribunals. They live in remote areas, and their few resources are being stretched to the limit.
There's a need for a federal fund to enable first nations to get the resources to deal with complaints, particularly complaints that may have large ramifications for a number of first nations or that may raise questions regarding the scope of section 35 rights. In other words, there needs to be a fund that will allow first nations to be resourced to handle test cases and other complaints with broad implications.
Finally, it's been noted that this may lead to challenges to not only the operations of first nations governments but to certain key provisions of the Indian Act, including the status and membership provisions and other provisions. This amendment should not be a back-door way of dismantling the Indian Act.
The government, particularly the Department of Indian Affairs, has known for years that there are fundamental problems with the status and membership provisions of the Indian Act. It has avoided these for.... The temporary band-aid was Bill C-31. They said, “This will last a generation.” That generation is up.
Status and membership issues are increasingly moving into focus in aboriginal communities, with the potential—I'm just talking about potential implications of this act—of leading to challenges to the status, membership, and other key provisions of the act. It is very important that the Crown be proactive in initiating a consultation process with first nations on how the status and membership provisions of the Indian Act should be developed on a go-forward basis, taking into consideration human rights and other issues, in particular the authority and jurisdiction of first nations to be self-defining and determine their membership.
I urge you to not underestimate the potential complexity and difficulty that this legislation may raise for first nations. No one is arguing against this in principle. But to push forward at a pace that doesn't attempt to recognize, accommodate, and reconcile not only the rights but the interests involved here would be reckless and unfortunate, particularly when there is a better and more cautious option to achieve the same results. I urge you to be respectful of first nations and their rights and circumstances in the manner in which you go about amending this act.
Thank you.
