Thank you, Mr. Chair. It's good to be back.
I want to thank you for inviting me here to talk about this really important topic. It is complex, and I know it's kind of a vexing issue for a number of first nations and first nations individuals.
Just by way of background, I'm a member of the Haida Nation in British Columbia. I'm also a practising lawyer. I've been practising in the aboriginal law area for the last 15 years throughout western Canada. Prior to that I spent four and a half years working for what was then the Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development. I spent all of six weeks doing estates and got out of there and moved to lands for another four and a half years. But even working on lands, estate issues always seemed to pop up when we were trying to do economic development on reserve, and it still does today. As part of my practice I do some estates work. I have probably half a dozen files, complex files, usually involving land, usually involving leases of first nation land, so developments on reserve. I don't do any off-reserve estates work, just the on-reserve stuff, so hopefully I can give you a little bit of my knowledge in terms of ways to maybe improve the system.
What I want to talk about, and I want to be really brief on this, is sort of at a very high level, and this is really a question for the committee: what is the issue that needs to be resolved here? Is there a better way to address the wills and estates of status Indians who reside on reserve? I think the answer is yes, but the solution is not simple.
I think it was in February or March my colleagues here on the panel and I were invited here to Ottawa to a think tank that the department had put on to look at potential solutions. A number of solutions came out of that, so when I'm speaking of these solutions, I didn't come up with them myself. These were some solutions that the group as a whole came up with. It was good because we actually had representatives from the province, from the public guardian and trustee, and I was there representing the Canadian Bar Association. My friends here from the IBA were there, as well as people from the department who actually work on a day-to-day basis with these matters.
I think there are four possible responses. The first one is the status quo. I always give this to my clients when I'm giving them advice: do nothing. It's always an option. I'll leave that to my friends from AANDC to talk about. The second is moving to provincial jurisdiction. The third is the first nations control, first nations optional legislation, so something like we just saw recently with the Family Homes on Reserves and Matrimonial Interests or Rights Act. The fourth is amendments to the Indian Act and the Indian estate regulations.
As I said, I'm not going to address the status quo. I just want to point out some issues, though, that came up in terms of moving to provincial jurisdiction. As you're aware, the law is different from province to province. There are significant costs to retaining lawyers and court applications. The question you might want to answer is whether the process is going to be more efficient by moving to a provincial system. My experience is that it isn't. There are questions in terms of how the provincial law will intersect with the Indian Act lands provisions. One of the things that I learned from our think tank was that the public trustee actually charges to manage estates, so there may be a cost either to the individual first nations people or to the department if you decide that you want to move to a provincial system.
There were some submissions that the CBA aboriginal law subsection did on Bill C-428 that identifies some of these issues. I'd recommend them to the committee.
The second option would be moving to first nations jurisdiction. The question that I have is, and my friends probably might answer this, is this something that first nations want? Is this something that first nations should be exercising jurisdiction over? Unlike lands, estates are fundamentally personal matters. Any process would have to be adequately funded if first nations decided to take on this responsibility.
The fourth option would be amending the act and regulations. I think this should be seriously considered.
Much of the current process is policy driven rather than legislation and regulations. It's a fairly lean set of laws that you're dealing with, and there are a number of administrative gaps, as I would call them. One example is whether or not an administrator has to pass their accounts at the end of the administration of the estate. This is something that's required provincially under the Trustee Act, but it seems to depend, when you're talking to the folks at AANDC.
In British Columbia, where I reside and do most of my work, there's been a new act put in place just recently, as of March 31, called the Will, Estates and Succession Act. There are opportunities to look at other pieces of provincial legislation, and to, I'll use the word “cherry-pick”, from these various provincial legislative regimes to develop a comprehensive code.
Finally, I think any recommendations to make changes to the current system must consider: first of all, the constitutional responsibility of Canada under section 91, item 24; the costs that may be associated with individuals moving to a different system from the current system; the cost to the Government of Canada of change, for example, the need to enter into some sort of memorandum of understanding with the provinces for fee for services to manage these small-value estates that the public trustee is now going to be responsible for; whether making changes will lead to efficiencies in the management of these estates; and finally, the long-term cost to families and first nations of lands being tied up in estates.
Thank you.
