Evidence of meeting #27 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was companies.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Tessari L'Allié  Founder and Executive Director, AI Governance and Safety Canada
David Duvenaud  Associate Professor of Computer Science, As an Individual
O'Neil  Vice-President, Research and Innovation, Simon Fraser University, As an Individual
James Elder  Professor and Research Chair, Human and Computer Vision, York University, Director, Centre for AI and Society, As an Individual
Teresa Scassa  Canada Research Chair in Information Law and Policy, Faculty of Law, Common Law Section, University of Ottawa, As an Individual
Billot  Chief Executive Officer, Scale AI

Parm Bains Liberal Richmond East—Steveston, BC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Thank you again to our witnesses for joining us.

I'm going to go to Dr. Elder.

I asked Dr. O'Neil from Simon Fraser University in British Columbia a similar question.

You mentioned it at the beginning of your intervention. What happens if we don't make these investments into the AI space and if we look at other international markets across the world? Can you expand on that a bit?

5:20 p.m.

Professor and Research Chair, Human and Computer Vision, York University, Director, Centre for AI and Society, As an Individual

Professor James Elder

Absolutely, I'm happy to do that.

I think it's like any disruptive technology, but on steroids. It's a really massive disruption this time, and the risks are great for our economy if we don't try to capitalize on the opportunities. As has been mentioned, there are a lot of opportunities that go beyond the development of these large language models in various dimensions of AI. It's not just language, of course, but computer vision or any kind of machine learning applied to data.

There's a time frame here that's important. There are a lot of rapid opportunities available and we don't have time to really sit around and think about it too long. We have to support innovation in this environment. What I think that means is really providing opportunities for small and medium-sized businesses to innovate. That should be through our tax system, through financial incentives, through infrastructure, as has been mentioned, and through better engagement among university research, industry innovators and domain applications.

That can be done at a federal level, where we really try to create an ecosystem that makes it easy for entrepreneurs to want to stay in Canada because all their business relationships are here—not all of them, but a lot of the important ones—and they have a really good pathway for human capital.

Parm Bains Liberal Richmond East—Steveston, BC

How behind are we? How can we catch up?

I'd like you to also comment on specific use cases demonstrating strong Canadian leadership or export potential.

5:25 p.m.

Professor and Research Chair, Human and Computer Vision, York University, Director, Centre for AI and Society, As an Individual

Professor James Elder

Sure. I think we're in a good place with respect to the training and university research. We still have great researchers across Canada.

My sense is that we're behind in providing the ecosystem needed for start-ups. We have a more risk-averse capital market, I think, than, for example, the U.S.

In terms of opportunities, there are just so many, as was mentioned in previous testimony: in agriculture, in natural resources and in smart cities.

Also, health care is a big one. I think there's a lot happening. For example, in health care, we have a lot of great work in medical imaging analysis and in robotics for health care and also for senior care, which is going to be a growing market over the next 10 to 20 years.

Also, in smart cities, of course, there are transformations, particularly around mobility, where we have a lead—historically, we're a leader—in telecommunications, as well as a lot of opportunities for optimization in telecom. I think what's really needed is sustained support for that ecosystem that lowers the friction between universities and this innovation in the private sector.

Parm Bains Liberal Richmond East—Steveston, BC

Thank you.

I'm going to go to Mr. Billot.

Can you talk a bit about the imbalance between the scale that we are developing in AI versus the risk side? Are we doing that simultaneously and combatting both of those initiatives?

5:25 p.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Scale AI

Julien Billot

I signed one of the petitions two years ago regarding the need for regulation. I definitely think, for industry, that you need to regulate, because you need trust in the system. If you are a stakeholder of any industry, a board member or a director of a company, you definitely don't want your company to be pinpointed because of issues with your AI solutions. There's a need for a regulatory framework for industry or at least a trusted environment in which to invest and protect stakeholders.

Right now, AI in industry, as I said, is causing far fewer regulation issues than the large language model, the deepfake models or anything else that is more for mass market. AI for industry is very limited to counting eggs, improving maintenance and creating digital twins, which are very operational things that, in fairness, don't raise any issue of regulation. When we look at projects, we always look at social impacts, green economy impacts, etc., but they don't cause any issues in terms of privacy or democratic issues. We're not really in that.

Talking about imbalance, for sure, on one side, there is the race to develop large language models and their implication, and agentic AI is raising a lot of questions. That's not really what we see in industry right now, which is really a much lower level AI that is not at all raising the same questions of regulation right now.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Mr. Bains.

Mr. Ste‑Marie, you have the floor for one minute.

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Ms. Scassa, I have two quick questions for you.

First, do you think the issues surrounding artificial intelligence are important enough to create a special committee to maintain an ongoing dialogue?

Second, Quebec has ended its artificial intelligence pilot project, which aimed to answer Canadians' most common questions, because of privacy issues. In Ottawa, that seems to be the model for the financial framework. Is it prudent to move in that direction right now?

5:25 p.m.

Canada Research Chair in Information Law and Policy, Faculty of Law, Common Law Section, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Dr. Teresa Scassa

I would say yes to the first question. I think a special committee would be very helpful.

I missed the end of the second question.

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Quebec had set up an artificial intelligence program to answer Canadians' questions, but it backtracked because of privacy issues. Ottawa seems to want this model to move forward. How prudent is that?

March 9th, 2026 / 5:30 p.m.

Canada Research Chair in Information Law and Policy, Faculty of Law, Common Law Section, University of Ottawa, As an Individual

Dr. Teresa Scassa

It's important to go about it carefully. It's important to know how to organize and govern it to protect privacy.

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Thank you very much, Ms. Scassa.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you, Mr. Ste‑Marie.

Thank you to the witnesses for being here today.

Colleagues, there is one quick thing to go over.

Witnesses, feel free to go, unless you want to stick around and listen to the guts of minutiae and technicalities at the industry committee. You're certainly welcome to stay.

One day, AI may do this for us.

We were going to look at the defence industrial strategy, but it sounds like there is a point of discussion that Madam Dancho is going to raise with colleagues about the potential for the inclusion of a couple more recommendations. Given that we're already at time today, what I would suggest is that, for Thursday's meeting—as we were aiming to do today, but we started late due to the technical difficulties—we simply cut the last round of questioning. That will save us 15 minutes or so. We might need a little bit more. We'll ask for a couple of additional resources for five or 10 minutes. That will give us the opportunity to finalize everything.

Does that work for everyone? If you have something right at one o'clock on Thursday, you may want to chat with your teams to see if you need five or 10 minutes of replacement, but we should be okay.

That was a good job, everyone. It was a very interesting start to this study.

The meeting is adjourned.