Evidence of meeting #51 for Industry and Technology in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was standards.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Massie  Assistant Deputy Minister, Small Business, Tourism and Marketplace Services, Department of Industry

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Good morning, everyone. I hope you all had a good week at home with your family, friends and the people you represent.

We are here to get going on Bill C-267.

I welcome Mr. Barsalou-Duval.

Mr. Barsalou‑Duval is replacing Mr. Ste‑Marie, who is absent today and for a few weeks due to other responsibilities. It's the same thing with Mr. Bains.

Mr. Bains and Mr. Ste-Marie have been seconded to the committee that has been created for the review of Bill C-39.

I can confirm that all tests have been completed.

Colleagues, we are going to spend the first hour today with our colleague MP Sari, who is going to have an opportunity to discuss his private member's bill, Bill C-267, an act to establish a national framework to promote the durability of electronic products and essential home appliances.

The second hour will feature officials from the department. We did carve out a bit of extra time to go in camera to discuss the three reports that we have to get off our plate, which I hope we will be able to move past quite speedily.

Mr. Sari, you have the floor for five minutes to present your bill.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

Thank you very much, colleagues. First of all, I want to apologize for my voice. This is due to some fatigue from a trip that was quite long.

First of all, thank you for welcoming me to your committee for its study of Bill C‑267. This is my first bill, even though this is my second year as the member elected in the riding of Bourassa.

To set the stage, I'd like to begin by explaining what I'm here to present to you today through a scenario. It's a scene that a lot of families are familiar with. Imagine a dishwasher, for example, that breaks down after four years. The technician arrives, tries to find the problem and announces that the part that needs to be replaced is no longer available or costs almost as much as a new appliance. The family then pays twice: first for the appliance they throw away, and then for the one they have to buy. The appliance ends up in the landfill.

Bill C‑267 is based on a reality we're all familiar with. It calls on the Department of Industry to develop in consultation with provinces, territories, consumers and industry a national framework on the sustainability and repairability of electronic products and essential home appliances. This framework focuses on three essential, and fairly simple, elements: first, informing consumers about a product's lifespan; second, ensuring access to parts and software support for a reasonable period of time; and third, clarifying the responsibilities of manufacturers, importers and distributors. The minister would table a report in Parliament within 18 months of the act coming into force, and it would be reviewed after five years.

On June 11, the House passed this bill at second reading by a vote of 192 to 131. I would also like to thank my colleagues from the Bloc Québécois, the NDP and the Green Party for their support. This vote says one thing: Sustainability is not about left or right; it's about the cost of living, competition and common sense.

Since June, I've had a number of meetings, a number of consultations and a number of analyses on a number of issues. I met with consumer groups like Option consommateurs, I studied reports from Protégez-Vous and Équiterre, and I also met with appliance manufacturers. Their concerns are relevant and serious, and I want to address them directly before you.

On the issue of safety, Bill C‑267 does not require anyone to open a compressor or a gas line. The framework can distinguish between parts available to the general public and those reserved for certified technicians, as the industry already does.

In terms of overlapping rules, Quebec, with its 2023 legislation, and Manitoba have taken the lead. The real risk today is the patchwork of rules that differ from province to province for the same imported product. Bill C‑267 calls for a national framework. This is precisely the kind of harmonization that the industry usually calls for. I repeat: this harmonization is a floor, not a ceiling. Quebec retains full latitude to go further.

In terms of consultation, manufacturers want to be at the table. They're right. I'm open to amendments that explicitly name them among consulted parties.

Other groups, on the other hand, are asking me to go further and include agricultural equipment, as well as vehicles or tools in other categories. The goal remains noble, interesting and relevant. However, my bill must be limited to home and office appliances for a very important reason. If there is an overlap between industries, we lose the very essence of the bill. A bill that tries to cover everything risks accomplishing nothing and dying on the Order Paper.

Bill C‑267 builds a strong foundation based on the products families use every day. The five-year review is the path to expanding the framework once it's proven. This bill does not create any new dependencies or impose any standards overnight. It provides clear direction, allows time to get things right and brings everyone together around the same table.

Families in Bourassa, just like those in Windsor, Joliette or Winnipeg, deserve to buy an appliance knowing how long it will last. They also need to know whether or not they'll be able to have it repaired when it breaks down.

As I said earlier, I understand the auto industry's appeal. Yesterday, I met with the Automotive Industries Association of Canada, or AIA Canada, and I share its objective. However, as I said earlier, vehicles fall under a separate regime, the Motor Vehicle Safety Act, and fall outside the scope of Bill C‑267. The auto sector, in my view, deserves its own legislation, and I'm prepared to work on that with colleagues from all parties. A bill that tries to cover everything, as I said earlier, risks achieving nothing.

What I want to do with this bill is to repair rather than discard, inform rather than leave people to guess, and collaborate rather than impose.

Thank you for listening. I look forward to your questions.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much for your opening remarks.

We're going to go right into questions.

Mr. Gill, the floor will be yours, sir, for six minutes.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Mr. Sari, I support the right to repair, but Canadians deserve more than good intentions and yet another government framework.

We have to give consumers enforceable rights, give the independent repair businesses a fair chance to compete, hold manufacturers accountable when they break the rules and make sure that when something goes wrong, Canadians know exactly who is responsible: more choices for consumers, less unnecessary red tape and real accountability from government as well as manufacturers.

Having said that, let's imagine that you have a two-year-old washing machine that needs a small inexpensive part, but the manufacturer won't supply it. What can the consumer legally demand under this bill? What can a consumer enforce today and what can that consumer expect once this bill is passed? For enforcement provisions, what more will there be in this bill for that consumer, sir?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

First of all, thank you very much for your question. It is essential and very relevant.

We have to be careful. The goal here is to lay the groundwork and consolidate all the requirements related to the right to repair, the right to information and the right to access replacement parts, of course. Once again, we have to be careful not to interfere in provincial matters. Remedies related to consumer rights fall more under provincial legislation. We have to be very careful about that. For example, in Quebec, when a claim needs to be filed, it is handled and managed at the provincial level.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

You bring up a good point, sir. Consumer protection is also a provincial responsibility. Your bill relies on consultation with the provinces, yet we've seen how difficult it has been for Ottawa to persuade provinces to remove interprovincial barriers, even when the economic benefits are very clear.

What will make this different? If Ontario adopts one set of repair rules and another province adopts different rules or none at all, will Canadians have different protections depending on where they live? If Ottawa and a province disagree, who is ultimately accountable? Who does that consumer call?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

It's very simple: Bill C‑267 establishes a floor, a minimum standard. After that, if the provinces want to go further, as Quebec is doing, in terms of recourse, requirements, access to information or labelling, that's up to them. The provinces are being given that latitude. However, when someone buys a phone in another province and the rules are different for the same phone, which was imported into Canada, we have a problem with consistency regarding the right to recourse.

That said, what we want to do here is establish a minimum standard. However, once again, if we want to spell this out explicitly in the bill through an amendment, I'm open to that.

11:10 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

The challenge, sir, is what we have talked about before in this committee: the issues about shared responsibility. When there is a shared responsibility, that means there is no responsibility, sadly. Other jurisdictions have tried this approach. France has introduced repairability scores, while some American states have taken a more targeted approach.

Why start a broad national framework instead of having clearly defined enforceable rights? For example, a label might tell a Canadian that a product is repairable, but that label is of little use if the necessary part is unavailable or the repair cost is as much as the new product, as you pointed out.

How will you measure whether this bill actually saves Canadian families money? What measurable reduction in repair costs or increase in a product's lifespan are you prepared to be held accountable for?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

I'll start by answering the second part of your question, because you mentioned something that is extremely important to me: metrics. I specialize in business intelligence and analytics. I often say that what isn't measured doesn't exist and that what is measured improves. That's very important. Here, we want to require numbers. As you said so well, what cannot be measured remains a mere intention.

So there are four metrics that we want to include in this bill: the lifespan of devices, the cost of a repair compared to buying new, the amount of electronic waste per capita, which can be reduced, and the jobs created in the repair sector. When we provide access to parts, when we provide information to repairers and when we provide instructions to repairers, we will create repair jobs in small and medium-sized businesses.

With respect to your first question, I'll go back to what I said earlier. Ottawa will facilitate the work to ensure access to information and parts, but it is up to the provinces to innovate and establish consumer recourse in this regard.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

How much time do I have, Chair?

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

You have seven seconds.

11:15 a.m.

Conservative

Harb Gill Conservative Windsor West, ON

All right. I will cede my time to you, Chair.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

It's so generous of you to start the week off that way. Thank you very much.

Mr. Ntumba, you have the floor for six minutes.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Good afternoon, Mr. Sari. How are you?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

That's the first question you're asking me. I'm doing very well, and I'm quite enthusiastic.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

During the pandemic, like many families, I found myself having to stay home, feeling a bit cooped up, because of safety measures that limited going out. I was at home with my wife and children, and one evening, the dryer completely broke down. It reawakened my childlike and resourceful side. Armed with my screwdriver and drill, I opened up the machine by myself at home. I went on YouTube to see how the thing worked. Fortunately, I was able to buy parts and repair my dryer all by myself at home. Since then, whenever something breaks at home, my brother, my mom or my sisters call me to ask me to fix it for them.

I really like the approach of this bill. It helps families, like mine, that have been through this in the past.

What challenges emerged from the various consultations you held in Bourassa?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

First of all, thank you very much for your question.

In my riding, as you know, the average household income is one of the lowest in Canada. In addition to this challenge, there is the challenge faced by small and medium-sized enterprises. In Bourassa, there are many repair shops for telephones, computers and even home appliances, but they're struggling to stay in business because they can't access replacement parts, instructions or procedures available online, especially in French, and can't locate existing information. So I think those are two things that need to be addressed to prevent families from having to buy another brand-new electronic device.

On Charleroi Street, Monselet Street and other streets in my riding, there are many repair shops that are hitting a wall, namely, a lack of access to information and replacement parts. This bill gives them the opportunity to keep their businesses running, whether in Montreal, Quebec or across Canada.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Sari.

What do you think of the 18‑month time frame? Is it sufficient to develop a robust framework, given the need for federal-provincial coordination?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

The short answer is yes.

Why now? It's because work has already been done. Reports have already been prepared by the Department of Industry. We're not reinventing the wheel. I think 18 months is very reasonable. We can always work on that, because a lot of studies and analyses have been done. We could reuse them and then discuss the framework again. As I said—and I'll say it again—this framework is not final. It will be reviewed every five years.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

Our government's priority is affordability for Canadians. Are there risks that increased sustainability requirements will increase upfront costs for the consumer?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

The short answer is no.

Now, how can this element really be justified? That's obviously by saying that it's already being done very well elsewhere, particularly in the United States, in a number of states, and in Europe. So we're not ahead of the game. On the contrary, we're lagging behind here in Canada in passing such a bill. When it comes to labelling, for example, we see that other countries are well ahead of us. I don't think fridges in those countries are more expensive than they are here. That's clear. It's not something that has driven up prices. Even in the United States, we see that things are moving in the same direction.

That said, we have to be careful. The devices covered by Bill C‑267 are, in the majority of cases, imported appliances. That's important. When they're imported, it's up to us, of course, to require certain things, and those things are required by the countries where these devices are manufactured.

So, here, it's a matter of aligning ourselves much more with international standards, not innovating ourselves. We mustn't see Bill C‑267 as something that puts us ahead of the curve, because we're quite behind in this regard in Canada. We need to have measures that allow consumers to choose repair.

Bienvenu-Olivier Ntumba Liberal Mont-Saint-Bruno—L’Acadie, QC

To wrap up, over the past two years, the Government of Canada has taken a number of steps to address issues related to the right to repair. Do you think your bill aligns with existing initiatives for the circular economy and consumer protection?

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

Not only does it align with them, but it is very complementary, even essential. That complementarity makes all of the things you talked about stronger and more relevant.

For example, in 2024, the Competition Act was amended for access to parts. That is a very important element. I believe it was Bill C‑244 and Bill C‑294. It opened up copyright locks, and that's important. Here, Bill C‑267 seeks to add two very important elements: parts sustainability and access to information.

In 2024, the government laid the foundation, and now Bill C‑267 is building the house, which I hope will be completed.

The Chair Liberal Ben Carr

Thank you very much, Mr. Ntumba. You are free to come to my home to solve all my problems at any time.

Abdelhaq Sari Liberal Bourassa, QC

I'd just like to add a comment.

It's good that the honourable member was able to repair his appliance, but we must be careful. Not everything can be repaired. For parts that may be dangerous, such as gas compressors, I always suggest calling in a specialist, rather than the member for Mont-Saint-Bruno—L'Acadie.