It seems to me that there's a consensus here that the country needs good information in order to run itself well. The question then comes down to the degree of compulsion and whether there are, both statistically and in other means, ways to get around the use of force.
I believe there are, and if I were a member of the committee, I think I would be spending my energies developing those.
I think it's noteworthy that institutions that use coercion in order to deal with people characteristically have relationship difficulties with the people they deal with. I don't think coercion is a useful sort of policy tool.
For heaven's sake, if the concern we have is around the value and importance of data, I don't know of any data that's more important to the running of the country than health care data, and we do not compel people to give up their health care data.