No, I would disagree with that. I think there is a fairly big difference between the proposed regime which would be authorizing organizations to share information for the purpose of investigating potential breaches versus the current regime where information can be shared only when an organization has reason to believe that there is a breach.
The difference is between investigating potential breaches or potential risk that a company thinks may be vulnerable to criminal activities, but without any evidence that there is such activity happening versus the current regime that requires reasonable grounds to believe that there is actually illegal activity occurring.