Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.
I would like to thank all of our witnesses for being here today. You all have some very interesting points of view.
My first question relates to the Spencer decision.
Mr. Geist, you have already testified before the Senate, but the decision had not yet been made. So I would like to hear your opinion on the decision and its possible repercussions on Bill S-4.
When the minister appeared, he seemed to think that no changes to Bill S-4 and the PIPEDA were required. I would appreciate hearing the other witnesses comments on this, if they have any.