It's not inherently, no. In other words, part of the value in a work of art is its perceived rarity and also the fact that someone owns it free of any and all encumbrances. The second you attach all sorts of other things to it, it becomes a less attractive thing. Again, the analogy would be why used books and CDs aren't subject to kickbacks every time they're sold.
It's going to be very hard for me to explain, but as I said, for matters of intellectual property and copyright, there are protections in place. In my opinion, the ARR is a lovely concept, but it's very dangerous in real life with respect to the effect it has on the marketplace.