Thank you.
Thank you to all the witnesses for coming today and giving us their very helpful perspective.
Mr. Osborne, I'm going to start with you.
We've heard a lot of testimony about where the legislation doesn't work. I think what this committee wants to do is to come out with an outcome to improve a piece of legislation that is intended to protect consumers and to allow for an ease of commerce to take place and to continue taking place into the future, because our economy depends on it. In principle, that's what we want to do.
You've talked about—and you've certainly written about—the fact that CASL does not help the consumer at all. I don't think I heard that from you today, but maybe you could clarify that, because I want to get to some recommendations through which this committee can be helpful. Can you talk to us about whether it is the definition of CEM..., and how we might look at clarifying that? From a recommendation standpoint, would clarifying CEM help?