Music Canada is the only name I see on the list, so it's not surprising to me that he got this part of the bill so wrong when he didn't talk to the groups most involved.
When I buy a book or a company buys a book, or when I buy a ticket to a performance or download a song, post-Napster, I pay to use it for my personal use or for that particular thing within the company. If a university wants to photocopy part of a textbook, it has to pay for copyright because it is using that for commercial purposes. Is that right? It is paying for that right.
Have any of you, or any of your organizations, been paid for any work of your members, artists and writers that's been used by OpenAI, ChatGPT, Microsoft or AWS? Have any of you been paid for any of that work so far?