We have been listening attentively and each one of you represents a particular sector or a particular issue. This committee of parliamentarians is really entrusted with looking at how the TPP benefits Canadians as a whole, and Canada itself. Looking at it that way, we think about good-paying jobs here in Canada, about competitiveness, and about profitability. We've heard differing opinions here from the different panellists.
Mr. Schumann, when did you first find out that the U.S. was excluded from chapter 12?