Thank you very much.
While I'm grateful for the opportunity to speak to you today, I do so with a profound sense of despair over what is happening with track two MAID. No matter how many people tell you that Bill C-7 is dangerous and no matter how many people die because they can't afford to live, it feels like a runaway train careening towards a human rights disaster. Ableism is so deeply embedded in our political and social structures that we don't see it as ableism but rather as a form of common sense.
The Supreme Court of Canada describes discrimination against people with disabilities as being premised on a distorted view that disability is a flaw that needs to be fixed or eradicated. It is precisely this ableist view of disability that fuelled Bill C-7 and is now killing disabled Canadians.
This ableism, sadly, has also permeated these hearings. Imagine that you are disabled. Perhaps you live in a one-room apartment. Perhaps you need diapers to deal with your incontinence. You've been listening to these hearings and heard your legislators talk about whether it would be better to be dead than to be like you. Far from feeling that your autonomy has been enhanced, you feel demoralized and depressed. You tell your doctor you are struggling, but she just reminds you that you are now eligible for MAID. Is it any wonder that so many disabled Canadians feel devalued and afraid?
If you take only one thing from my words today, it is this: There is only one safeguard that will protect people with disabilities from wrongful deaths, and that is reasonable foreseeability of natural death. That is the only safeguard that can prevent people from dying because they are too poor, too isolated or too exhausted from fighting for their survival to continue living. Death is the great equalizer. Everyone dies, and this is the only safeguard that removes making value judgments about the worth of disabled lives from the equation.
It is impossible to separate the suffering caused by disability from the suffering caused by the social, economic and political accompaniments of disability. If I cannot access smoke-free housing, is that my multiple chemical sensitivities or is that the inadequacy of social housing? If I can't afford an apartment with an elevator, is that my disability or my poverty? If I am facing institutionalization at 40 because the government won't provide me with home care to ensure I can get to the bathroom at night, is that my disability or is that the abject failure of the state to provide the basic necessities of life?
These situations have led to the deaths by MAID of real people who did not want to die. This is a system that would not provide Sathya Kovac with home care but gave her death by a house call. She wrote her own obituary before her death, saying, “It was not a genetic disease that took me out, it was a system.”
The Supreme Court of Canada has held in the death penalty context that one wrongful death is too many. I ask you how many wrongful deaths are too many for track two MAID? To those who say that MAID is just another form of health care, remember that it is legislated as an exemption to murder and aiding suicide, and that is the only reason Parliament has any jurisdiction. The Criminal Code makes explicit that ending a life is so serious that we don't allow people to consent to their own deaths. The MAID regime makes an exception to that, but only for disabled Canadians. Only their lives are not worth saving. How can you not see that this is discriminatory?
It is irresponsible to delegate the definition of murder and aiding suicide to doctors and ask us to trust a health care system that is strapped for resources and near the breaking point. When we look at Canada's record of eugenics, from residential schools to warehousing of the mentally ill and the sterilization of indigenous and disabled women and girls, we see that doctors were deeply implicated in all of these.
This government has focused not on eradicating the suffering of people with disabilities but rather on eradicating the sufferers. I urge this committee to take meaningful steps to prevent the impending human rights catastrophe that will be MAID for mental illness and to put an end to track two MAID.
Thank you.