We have a problem with this amendment in several areas. First of all, it doesn't talk about if a member is removed for a cause, and it also says that the member “shall continue”, which means the chair has no say in the matter. We don't think that's appropriate.
It also talks about the committee “giving its decision”. This committee doesn't render decisions; it gives advice. Frankly, we think it's probably outside the scope, but I think that would have been brought up if the legislative clerk had thought so as well.
But we don't think the way it is written it is technically correct. It is not accurate and it should be further considered. As has been stated by the JAG, this is one of those areas that's for further consideration. We can't support this. There are too many things wrong with it.