Evidence of meeting #37 for National Defence in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was companies.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Lussier  President and Chief Executive Officer, Aéro Montréal
Mueller  President and Chief Executive Officer, Aerospace Industries Association of Canada
Asselin  Chief Executive Officer, U15 Canada
Ziadé  Co-Chair, Alliance of Canadian Defence Companies

The Chair Liberal Charles Sousa

Thank you.

I'm sorry, Mr. Anderson—next round.

Ms. Lapointe, it's over to you for five minutes.

Viviane LaPointe Liberal Sudbury, ON

Thank you, Chair.

Mr. Ziadé, I really liked a number of the points you raised in your remarks.

Some witnesses in this study have talked about the importance of regional industrial capacity. In northern Ontario, for example, we have strong mining, advanced manufacturing, automation and dual-use technology expertise, but companies often feel disconnected with the defence sector. It's not a field they normally play in.

In your opinion, what needs to happen to better connect regions like ours to Canada's broader defence industrial strategy?

5:30 p.m.

Co-Chair, Alliance of Canadian Defence Companies

Paul Ziadé

There's a role to play. The supply chain in defence is very complex, and even some industries that are not traditionally considered to be traditional defence industries can play a part. I think something was mentioned earlier—and this applies not only to SMEs but also to non-traditional defence companies—about what is going to be required for them to participate in the defence renaissance that we're going through right now.

A phrase I use a lot is that it's more than just rebranding. There is a lot required from government, from industries and from experts to help them get through all the certifications and the regulatory piece, because it's a very complex environment. I think the government is hitting on all the right notes with the defence industrial strategy, but I'm sure some of my colleagues have some interesting points to make on that.

Viviane LaPointe Liberal Sudbury, ON

For a country of our size, where do you see the right balance between the need to work with trusted allies and the need for domestic capacity, particularly in areas tied to national security and critical supply chains? What is that balance?

5:35 p.m.

Co-Chair, Alliance of Canadian Defence Companies

Paul Ziadé

I can give you my own perspective. In the long term, we can do a lot more than we currently do. That is absolutely it. The build-partner-buy framework is precisely that we cannot immediately do everything.

I'll touch a little on a previous question. In this urgent moment in which we find ourselves, there's a lot more we can do now, because the technologies of 21st-century warfare, defence or deterrence are not 10-year or 15-year projects; they are in autonomy, in cyberspace. These are things that we can ramp up much more quickly. We've seen our allies do it even in Europe, which is not traditionally known to be a very fast-moving jurisdiction. They have lots of very exciting companies right now selling to their armed forces in record time, and we can do that as well. We can bring up that proportion much more quickly than a lot of people probably think is possible.

Viviane LaPointe Liberal Sudbury, ON

Mr. Mueller, because Canada's aerospace sector is so highly integrated into allied supply chains—particularly with the United States and with NATO partners—and as Canada expands defence spending and industrial capacity, where do you see the strongest opportunities for Canadian aerospace firms within those allied ecosystems?

5:35 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Aerospace Industries Association of Canada

Mike Mueller

A zero-for-zero trade framework for aerospace is absolutely critical across the board, and we've had that in place since 1979—the WTO rules. I'm very encouraged by the government's push on new free trade agreements. I think of all the work that Minister Sidhu has been doing across the board. I think of Mercosur as one of the key markets that we have right now.

There are opportunities everywhere in the world. We strongly support the Prime Minister's push for Europe. I was just in Budapest talking about the EU SAFE agreement that Canada is now a part of. There are large opportunities in eastern Europe.

Canada is blessed to have an aerospace industry that can think of, design, certify and sell right across the board, both on the civil and the defence side of things. We need to continue to double down on that and to have those free trade agreements continue to give us access to some of these defence frameworks that are happening. It's not an easy ride sometimes, but having the government open those doors, either through free trade agreements or through some of the funding mechanisms, is absolutely critical for our industry. It's global in nature, and we need to be a part of that.

Viviane LaPointe Liberal Sudbury, ON

Ms. Lussier, do you want to add any comments?

5:35 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Aéro Montréal

Mélanie Lussier

While my colleague was answering, I was thinking of all the businesses that have told us in recent months that supply chains are indeed closely linked. That's a good thing. It took us years to build the supply chains that are linked to the United States or Europe. It's going to be extremely hard to unravel them, and it's inadvisable.

The number of opportunities is increasing rather than decreasing. Our relationship with the United States remains extremely significant. We need to remember that 70% of what we make is exported to the United States. Therefore, we absolutely have to keep what we've had since 1979, meaning zero tariffs for all trade, because parts related to the aerospace sector can cross the border up to eight times. It's very significant.

That said, we are naturally very pleased with the opportunities Europe represents.

The Chair Liberal Charles Sousa

Thank you.

Mr. Ste‑Marie, you have the floor.

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

My questions are still for you, Ms. Lussier and Mr. Mueller. I'm going to ask you two questions at once.

First, to replace the CP‑140 Aurora aircraft, National Defence awarded the contracts to Boeing, so the aircraft will be built in the United States. However, we have learned that there will be a significant delay. If I'm not mistaken, it is three years. Do you think that, given the new defence strategy and the delays, there could be a review of the agreement, or is it already too late to buy Canadian in this case?

Second, Ms. Lussier, in your presentation, you said that, in the defence sector, it's easier to sell to other countries than within Canada. Should the national strategy address that?

5:40 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Aéro Montréal

Mélanie Lussier

I'll start with your second question first.

In fact, I said that, historically, some businesses, particularly SMEs, told us that it was easier for them to sell their products to other armies than to the Canadian army. However, the strategy's signals are really extremely encouraging.

What they are telling us now is that they see a real path opening up and that they will have support to be able to break into the market, as I mentioned in my remarks.

What's more, we really sense a willingness on the part of the Canadian government. Not only that, but we sense a complete change of rhetoric, with the government saying that it will first look at whether anything is available here.

In terms of contracts that have already been awarded or will be awarded, our aerospace cluster never takes a position on one candidate or another. Naturally, you will understand that I have as many members in Boeing's supply chain as in other chains.

However, we're looking at one aspect very carefully: We want to make sure that investments have industrial and technological benefits in Canada. For each of the contracts, whether it be the one you were talking about or those to come, we will make sure, when we need to make purchases, that there are real benefits with real projects. The aerospace cluster received an investment as part of the spinoffs. We're going to make sure that we increase the leverage that these contracts can bring to the country.

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Thank you, Ms. Lussier.

Mr. Mueller, what do you have to say about that?

5:40 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Aerospace Industries Association of Canada

Mike Mueller

Contracts that are ongoing, I can't speak to. It would probably be better to talk to the CAF or PSPC on some of those matters.

Again, industry requires the long-term certainty piece. On all these questions, that's really why we've been pointing to the need for an industrial strategy. Are there going to be bumps along the road in implementing that strategy? Absolutely, there will be, but if we had had a strategy five or 10 years ago, a lot of the challenges that we're seeing on different pieces would have been addressed.

The big piece that we've been looking for is getting away from that transactional approach. How do you bring industry and government together to have these conversations earlier in the requirement-setting cycle?

I'll be very interested to see how the defence advisory forum is going to be structured. We're looking forward to having a seat at that table to make sure that we're bringing industry and government together, but it has to be very focused. It can't be another box-checking exercise for government. It has to include some meaningful discussions taking place with industry, with problem sets coming to industry, industry giving advice to the government and government being held accountable as to why they are taking the advice—or maybe why they aren't taking the advice.

We have a lot of work to do across the board on some of these things. I'm encouraged that we're going in the right direction, but we still have a way to go.

Gabriel Ste-Marie Bloc Joliette—Manawan, QC

Thank you, Mr. Mueller.

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

The Chair Liberal Charles Sousa

Thank you.

Mr. Kibble, it's back to you, sir.

5:40 p.m.

Conservative

Jeff Kibble Conservative Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, BC

Mr. Ziadé, I appreciated your comments about Canadian expertise and innovation, and I couldn't agree more.

However, do you think this committee should consider recommending that the government formally propose to its allied partners, such as the U.K., Germany, France and Korea, an immediate framework for an interval of lend-lease, training and co-development agreements to bridge between current Canadian operational requirements and the long-term 2030-35 DIS deliverables?

Please answer briefly with a yes or no.

Also, how would your organization collaborate on such a plan to address that short-term challenge, and what would it contribute?

5:40 p.m.

Co-Chair, Alliance of Canadian Defence Companies

Paul Ziadé

It's an interesting idea. We'll have to see what the membership thinks of it.

It kind of bridges that gap, because we're trying to send the message very strongly that the IP ownership is very important. I think that if Canadians are to get on board in the long term with the idea that we need to spend more money on defence, they need to see the economic benefits come back to them. In the 21st century, that is through IP ownership. It is not solely through job creation.

In terms of what our organization can do, we do not charge any membership fees. We are very lean right now, but we are very happy to help with the thought leadership and even get the opinions of our wider membership.

5:45 p.m.

Conservative

Jeff Kibble Conservative Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, BC

Thank you very much.

I'd like to pivot a little and focus on the Permanent Joint Board on Defence's being paused and Mr. Colby's challenge. This should be a wake-up call, I believe, to all Canadians.

Where can Canadian defence production add value that helps close the U.S. production capacity shortfall and, in doing so, let our country answer the Under Secretary of War's challenge with capability rather than rhetoric?

I'll start with Ms. Lussier.

5:45 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Aéro Montréal

Mélanie Lussier

I don't want to say that we can help anywhere and everywhere, but we almost can. As I mentioned, the supply chains are really well intertwined. Most of my members have clients in the United States or are suppliers already, so we can provide.... That's one of the messages that we're always saying: In Quebec, we can build an aircraft from A to Z, as well as helicopters, drones, etc., which we can certify. We can help in all the fields needed by our allies.

5:45 p.m.

Conservative

Jeff Kibble Conservative Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, BC

Thank you.

Mr. Mueller, would you care to comment on that?

5:45 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Aerospace Industries Association of Canada

Mike Mueller

We have very highly integrated defence supply chains across the board. A lot of Canadian companies have direct contracts with the USAF, the United States Air Force, for example, so keeping those linkages very live....

I would also say critical minerals. To me, that is the low-hanging fruit. They're absolutely critical for the development of aerospace products. We're a world leader in that. I'm encouraged to see the DIS have some sort of a focus on that. It comes down to execution and having those discussions across the board.

We have the capacity, the ability, to do a lot of these pieces. I'm having weekly conversations with my counterparts in the U.S., so there's a lot of collaboration there and right across the world.

Jeff Kibble Conservative Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, BC

Thank you.

Mr. Ziadé, I'll ask for your organization's perspective on the same question.

5:45 p.m.

Co-Chair, Alliance of Canadian Defence Companies

Paul Ziadé

I would echo my colleagues' remarks. We can do quite a bit right now. Upstream in the supply chain, in critical minerals, there is an immediate opportunity where we can definitely contribute.

5:45 p.m.

Conservative

Jeff Kibble Conservative Cowichan—Malahat—Langford, BC

That's perfect.

How much time do I have, Mr. Chair?