Evidence of meeting #50 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was reactor.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Mousseau  Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual
Boutziouvis  Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis
Coupland  Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada
Gitzel  Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation
Cameron  Manager, Public Affairs and Communications, Canadian Nuclear Isotope Council
Gidda  Global Leader, Future Energy, GHD Limited
Varah  Nuclear Energy Leader, GHD Limited

6:30 p.m.

Conservative

Gaétan Malette Conservative Kapuskasing—Timmins—Mushkegowuk, ON

Would you add to that, Mr. Gitzel?

6:30 p.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation

Tim Gitzel

I think nuclear power is fantastic. It's 24-7 baseload power and all of the attributes that you have with that. If you can produce isotopes on top of that, there's huge value to that. It's not just financial value. There's value in selling the technology. You can say, “Do you know that we save lives with this nuclear power as well, and that you can produce lutetium, cobalt and the other pieces that are used?”

Part of Bruce Power's story is that it's producing great electricity 24-7, but it's also sending a lot of isotopes to hospitals to save lives. It's a great addition to the nuclear power.

6:35 p.m.

Conservative

Gaétan Malette Conservative Kapuskasing—Timmins—Mushkegowuk, ON

This goes to you again, Mr. Gitzel.

You have 45 years in the nuclear sector. With your experience, if you could change one thing in the federal regulatory process to make us the world leader, what would you do tomorrow morning?

6:35 p.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation

Tim Gitzel

Thank you for the question.

When I started, I think Joe Clark was the prime minister. I was 17.

I would speed up the approval process, if we can. Move more quickly. Learn from other jurisdictions. Work with the U.S. Work with the U.K. Work with France. France has 54 reactors, and 70% of their power is nuclear. Let's work with them to share experiences. They do that. They had all of them up at Cigar Lake last summer. All the regulators got together and came up.

Don't replicate the same studies every time on a reactor design. The U.S. and the U.K. have approved the AP1000. I know Canada's looking at it. I know Pierre Tremblay and his team are looking at it. Use some of the work that's already done; don't replicate the work every time.

6:35 p.m.

Conservative

Gaétan Malette Conservative Kapuskasing—Timmins—Mushkegowuk, ON

I have another question for you, Mr. Gitzel.

I'm representing northern Ontario, and in many of our communities, you fly in diesel. You don't even barge it in; you fly it in.

Are the small reactors a technology that could benefit some of these communities?

6:35 p.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation

Tim Gitzel

That's a great question. Yes, 100%, and guess what? We're looking at that for our mines in northern Saskatchewan, which are 750 kilometres north of Saskatoon, where we truck in diesel and propane every day.

Westinghouse, for instance, has a five-megawatt reactor—the eVinci—that we're working on. Somebody mentioned that the U.S. is looking at putting them on their military bases. Yes, we can do that, and Canada's doing it now as well. I think it's in New Brunswick that they picked BWXT to work on a microreactor. Yes, and it would save all the diesel, for sure.

Gaétan Malette Conservative Kapuskasing—Timmins—Mushkegowuk, ON

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mr. Danko, you are the most popular politician in the House today.

Some hon. members

Oh, Oh!

Sherry Romanado Liberal Longueuil—Charles-LeMoyne—Greenfield Park, QC

You have the mic.

John-Paul Danko Liberal Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas, ON

Thank you, Chair.

I want to start by saying how refreshing it is to be having this conversation in the context of the understanding that Canada, along with the rest of the world, is transitioning to an electric economy. That's the baseline that we're having this discussion on, which, as I said, I find very refreshing.

I want to start on the radioisotope side. I'm a representative of Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas. McMaster is in my riding. We have AtomVie and Fusion Pharmaceuticals as those next-generation pharmaceutical companies that are, as you said, Mr. Cameron, located local to the production. They're also doing the processing. Fusion Pharmaceuticals, in particular, was sold to AstraZeneca recently for $2.4 billion.

It's not just the sale of the isotopes or the market for isotopes; the real growth industry that I see is in the processing facilities and the expertise that's needed.

You talked about having production and processing together, but part of the nature of radioisotopes is that they have to be together. How important is it for the growth of those industries to build on both those factors?

6:35 p.m.

Manager, Public Affairs and Communications, Canadian Nuclear Isotope Council

Evan Cameron

As you say, it's inherent. I think you're referring to the half-lives. These isotopes have very short half-lives in some cases.

For example, lutetium has a half-life of about five days, give or take. It's currently processed in Germany. Think of it going from Bruce Power to Pearson and over to Germany to be processed, and then to patients, sometimes back in Canada, sometimes abroad. It's really quite a trek.

That is exactly why the CNIC feels so strongly that processing should be happening locally. I'll clarify that I don't mean locally as in 20 minutes away, like McMaster to AtomVie. Several jurisdictions—China is certainly one, but there are others—are doing the complete processing on site where they're producing the isotope. It's under one licence.

Obviously, there would be some regulatory factors that would need to be considered, and I don't have the regulations in front of me, but the key opportunity is really to not just do it locally but to co-locate processing and production. As I mentioned, Bruce Power is beginning to do so with lutetium. That's really the missing piece of the puzzle, in our view. We have the entire isotope supply chain in Canada, here at home, but it's just the processing, particularly on emerging isotopes, that is really the barrier. I would say that's very important.

John-Paul Danko Liberal Hamilton West—Ancaster—Dundas, ON

Thank you.

Mr. Gidda and Mr. Varah, in your opening statements you talked about the workforce development and developing the people and skills that we will need for the nuclear industry. I think that's a core consideration for the government. As we're investing in nuclear, whatever the technology is, whether it's AP1000, CANDU, SMRs or microreactors, we still need that skilled workforce to build them and operate them.

How do we make sure we have that specialized workforce? What steps can we take as we move forward with Canada's nuclear strategy?

6:40 p.m.

Global Leader, Future Energy, GHD Limited

Tej Gidda

I do hold the title of adjunct professor at a couple of Ontario universities, and I think this problem is endemic, not just among the specialist side of nuclear but in the rest of it as well—the so-called “balance of plant”, as we call it.

If I think of Ontario Tech University and how many nuclear specialists they're putting out per year, it's a very small number. If I think about the number of civil engineers, electrical engineers, mechanical engineers and geotechnical engineers we need to support those specialist trades in actually building these things and designing these things, the number of construction specialists is also very limited in reality when you look at the figures. There's a competition here between infrastructures. This is not just about nuclear. We are building many different pieces of infrastructure across this country that also have a demand for that talent. We are seeing that demand and that competition for talent across markets at the moment.

Part of our message is, if we really want to build 10 reactors, which I think is eminently possible, we're going to have to think differently about who we're training and in what quantity across this country.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you so much. Thanks to you both.

Mr. Simard, you have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

There are currently four nuclear power plants in Canada: three in Ontario and one in New Brunswick. That's roughly 15% of Canada's electricity generation. If the government pursues its goal of doubling electricity generation by 2050, that suggests that four additional nuclear power plants could be built.

What might it cost to build these power stations? I'm not asking you to go out on a limb and speculate too much, but let's say we settle on a particular technology and try to double nuclear generation—what might that cost, roughly speaking?

6:40 p.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation

Tim Gitzel

Thank you very much.

Right now, there are 20 nuclear reactors in Canada. I think there are 19 that are operating or available in Ontario. Gentilly, of course, is not. Then there's Point Lepreau in New Brunswick. Also, of course, OPG is building the first SMR.

To double, you'd need another 14 or 15 nuclear plants, which is exactly what Ontario has planned: four big units, 4,800 megawatts, at Bruce Power; 10,000 megawatts, OPG, at Wesleyville; plus the other three SMRs they're talking about building.

Our good friend Scott Moe in Saskatchewan is talking about two or three large reactors. Why? Artificial intelligence. We haven't talked about that yet. Keep your eye on that. Whether you believe it or not, they're building a $52-billion artificial intelligence data centre outside of Regina. It takes one reactor just to run that alone. The power needs are astronomical.

How much does it cost? I guess we'll see. We put estimates...I think you heard Sam talk about $8 billion to $10 billion per 1,000 megawatt to 1,100 megawatt unit. It'll be something like that.

We built two in the U.S., Vogtle 3 and Vogtle 4, at Augusta, Georgia. Vogtle 3 was expensive and overpriced, and it took a long time. The second one took 30% less time and 30% less money. We have to build the first one, and that's why everybody wants to be second. They don't want to build that first one, but once you get going.... As I said, the Chinese are building them in five years for $5 billion. They're good. They're cookie cutter. That's how they build them.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Thank you to all of our witnesses.

Thank you, colleagues, for great questions with great answers. There were some pithy phrases today: “a mad dash to go second”, “big or small, we need them all”, and a great geochemistry lesson—thank you, Ms. McKelvie.

Colleagues, thank you.

Again, thank you to our witnesses.

We're adjourned.