Evidence of meeting #50 for Natural Resources in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was reactor.

A video is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Mousseau  Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual
Boutziouvis  Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis
Coupland  Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada
Gitzel  Chief Executive Officer, Cameco Corporation
Cameron  Manager, Public Affairs and Communications, Canadian Nuclear Isotope Council
Gidda  Global Leader, Future Energy, GHD Limited
Varah  Nuclear Energy Leader, GHD Limited

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thank you all for being here today. This is an important study. To those of you I know as witnesses, and your teams in the gallery, it's nice to see you again. To those I don't know, it's still nice to see you, just in a different context.

It does feel like we are looking at a bit of a global nuclear renaissance. I think that comes at the right time as Canada looks at its electricity plans going out to 2050 and beyond. Of course, nuclear is 15% of our nation's generation right now. It's an important part of our mix. If we wanted even just to sustain that mix, it would mean significant build-outs.

I really want to focus my questions in this round on nuclear as a global industry, including medical isotopes. I want to, in particular, canvass all three of our witnesses for their view of global opportunities as well as global challenges and do a bit of a tour of the table for what we need to think about in terms of Canada as a player in a global industry and building on the success that we've seen in this space.

Maybe we can start with you, Mr. Boutziouvis.

October 28th, 2026 / 5:10 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

Thank you.

First, Canada has a tremendous advantage. CANDU reactors can produce medical isotopes. It's because of their physics, but I won't get into it.

Canada is a world leader in the production of several types of isotopes, both at Bruce Power and at Ontario Power Generation, and looks forward to exporting even more isotopes abroad, including exotic isotopes that fight cancer, such as those in the lutetium class, or that make sure that instruments are clean, such as cobalt-60. Starting from that base is an incredible, positive, competitive advantage.

Provinces like Ontario have been looking to expand and develop the isotope business by getting further into the market by adding value and developing even more exotic-type isotopes. That's because the market for isotope production could reach over $33 billion in the near future. It has taken off, and it is set to dramatically expand as countries develop greater capacity in their health care systems in order to be able to provide such life-saving health improvements.

The market for isotope development in Canada, as I said, is quite strong. I think it's in moving up the value chain that more could be done. At present, a lot of the isotope production is exported. Value is added, and then it's reimported back. Where we could really use some kind of industrial development is in entering into that higher-value-added space. At the same time, if CANDU is chosen for various projects across Canada, each of the provinces will have that capacity to produce more isotopes.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

I wouldn't mind asking you if you could talk about that isotope opportunity, as well as the broader opportunities in other markets.

When I talk to other nations, I know that one of the things we tell them about CANDU reactors is this isotope capacity. How are you seeing the global opportunities and global views of CANDU technology at this time?

5:15 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

There's very strong interest in CANDU technology around the world. Our top markets at present, in terms of prospects, are Poland, Turkey, the United States of course, China perhaps, and ASEAN nations such as the Philippines, Indonesia and potentially even Vietnam. We are actively pursuing those markets in competition with the other five, and we're up for it. We're game. We have very strong support from Export Development Canada, the Canadian Commercial Corporation and Global Affairs Canada, as well as, broadly, members of the Canadian cabinet.

With respect to isotopes, here is one anecdote. Sixty per cent of China's production of isotopes is done right beside the two CANDU reactors. They've built an isotope production unit and development unit right beside the two little CANDUs, as they call them.

I can also say to you that Poland, Turkey and Romania all want to build CANDUs in order to develop their health sciences and to develop isotopes.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thank you.

Mr. Coupland, you said, “nuclear is a mad dash to go second”, which I love. I think that's going to be a very quotable quote in our report.

Let's broaden that. What should we keep in mind when we look at the streamlining efforts of the U.S. and the U.K.? Are there lessons to be learned? If we were going to streamline based on how they have approached it, what have they learned about streamlining that we might be able to take into the Canadian context?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Give a quick answer, please.

5:15 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

The primary things are focusing on safety concerns and getting rid of extra layers of duplication in terms of the regulatory process. They've done a good job of streamlining. They've streamlined some of their hearing processes in the way they look at projects.

Corey Hogan Liberal Calgary Confederation, AB

Thank you.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Thank you both.

Mr. Simard, you have the floor for six minutes.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair.

Thank you to the witnesses who've joined us.

Mr. Mousseau, I see this study as an opportunity to define the government's best strategy in line with its aim to double the electricity supply. I found it interesting that you concluded your opening statement by saying that we might need to identify other sectors.

One of your colleagues, Mr. Pineau, with whom I know you disagree on occasion, appeared before us earlier this week. Perhaps you will find common ground on one point. Mr. Pineau told us that he estimated the cost of nuclear-generated electricity at $110 per megawatt-hour, that of hydroelectricity in Quebec at $40 per megawatt-hour and that of electricity generated by small modular nuclear reactors at $150 per megawatt-hour, excluding operating costs. This shows that these are very high costs—these are very expensive projects. Government resources are not unlimited.

Is it a good strategy right now for Canada to invest significant resources in nuclear power—knowing, as you said, that storage technologies and intermittent electricity generation technologies, such as solar and wind, are developing so quickly?

5:15 p.m.

Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual

Normand Mousseau

There are two roles. Nuclear power, as I was saying, has an advantage due to its predictability and high capacity factor. Therefore, I believe that in a system which, unlike Quebec's, does not have hydroelectricity with storage capacity, nuclear power can play a foundational role—but further studies are needed to determine the extent to which it is useful for reasons of resilience. Nuclear power is very expensive compared to other technologies, but it offers certain advantages in terms of resilience, safety and diversification. That, in my view, is how we should assess nuclear power's role.

For instance, the Ontario project, in my opinion, relies far too heavily on nuclear power, especially given the differences between summer and winter, which make generation very costly. That's the required analysis, in my view.

In addition, in this context, we must also look at other technologies that will support the rest of the electricity generation fleet, such as large-scale and long-term storage. We're talking about dozens or even hundreds of terawatt hours of storage for more than a few days, a few weeks or a few months. We can then put together a system that will not be too costly, but will provide the security needed to deal with the problems. If we end up with a month without wind, or with little wind or little sun, we still need a minimum amount of electricity to keep things running.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

Thank you very much.

I don't know if the type of analysis you're talking about currently exists.

5:20 p.m.

Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

That's unfortunate.

I'd like to talk to you about one of my concerns.

We know that a nuclear project takes quite a long time to complete, and I often see advances in storage, particularly in China. Since I started following the issue of electrification, I've noticed quite considerable progress. I wonder whether other countries facing energy challenges see things the same way as I do—and whether, as part of their strategy, they might be more inclined to consider intermittent electricity generation combined with storage solutions, rather than investing in technologies such as CANDU reactors, for example.

If we bear in mind the cost and time frame for these projects, is there a future for nuclear power, given the storage developments on the horizon?

5:20 p.m.

Scientific Director, Trottier Energy Institute, Polytechnique Montréal, As an Individual

Normand Mousseau

Once again, it is a question of balance. If we want to move away from gas and oil, we cannot have an energy mix consisting solely of intermittent renewable sources. In Europe, for example, it was very hot last May, and there wasn't much wind. There was plenty of sunshine, but little wind. That meant running other thermal power stations—particularly gas-fired ones—to meet demand. We still need a guaranteed supply of electricity, whatever the weather conditions. That, to me, is where the value of nuclear power lies.

As I said, no studies have been carried out in Canada to determine whether nuclear power should account for 5%, 10% or 15% of electricity generation, taking into account how this balances with new electricity transmission lines that would reduce risks across Canada. We therefore need to carry out more sophisticated analyses, rather than simply saying that we are going to build more nuclear reactors or that we don't want any nuclear reactors in the rest of Canada. Once again, some provinces—such as Quebec—are different because they are so self-sufficient in hydroelectricity that nuclear power has no significant strategic role to play.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

If you were to make a recommendation, then, it would be to determine the level of nuclear energy we need. I'm not trying to put words in your mouth. I wonder whether, at some point—

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

That was a yes, and you're out of time.

Mario Simard Bloc Jonquière—Hébertville—Pays-des-Bleuets, QC

That was a yes. Okay.

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Colleagues, we're going to go on to our second round.

Mr. Patzer, we're going to start with you.

5:20 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Thank you very much, Mr. Chair, and thank you to all the witnesses for being here.

I'm going to start with you, Mr. Coupland.

You've talked about X-energy being a different type of reactor from existing ones and being a perfect fit for Canada. Could you go into maybe a bit more detail as to why you say that?

5:20 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

Thank you.

If I were to sum up what makes X-energy distinct in a single word, it would be flexibility. The Xe-100 provides a flexibility that the large reactors and light water SMRs do not provide. I talked earlier about our ability to produce both electricity and high-temperature steam that can be used for cogeneration. It will enable us, as I mentioned, to decarbonize high-emitting industry. That's one significant advantage that other reactors don't have.

The use of a four-pack design, which we have, allows a lot of flexibility in location, use and construction of units. Some sites, like our Dow project, are only going to use four units. Others, such as AWS, which needs all the electricity it can get, will use the full 12-pack. We can also be used for distributed generation, depending upon the locations. Maybe you have a need for 320 megawatts of electricity. Maybe you have a location that needs a certain amount of thermal heat, and you can put the rest to the grid. Maybe you have a location that needs 600. There's a lot of flexibility in that.

The other thing is that we can provide variations, any combination of heat and electricity—again, flexibility. Because we use helium as a coolant, and we can use air-cooled condensers, there is much lower water usage. We use about two Olympic-sized swimming pools per reactor per month. It's a lot of flexibility. We don't have to be on the Great Lakes. We don't have to be on a large body of water. That differentiates us from other reactors.

We have the ability to load-follow. That was something that the professor mentioned. Our reactor can reduce or raise power from 100% to 40% in 5% intervals over 12 minutes. We can go up and down. That provides us an opportunity to be a good partner for intermittent technologies or renewables like wind and solar.

The other thing I'll note is that we have a very small footprint. It's 35 to 60 acres for a four-pack. By using the intrinsically safe Triso-X fuel, our reactors have a much smaller emergency planning zone, so it allows our units to be put much closer to the end-user.

For all those reasons, I think we're a very good fit. There are multiple uses in multiple places that our technology can fit where the larger reactors can't fit. That's not to say there's not a use for the larger reactors. I don't mean to imply that, but we can do things they can't do and in places they can't go.

5:25 p.m.

Conservative

Jeremy Patzer Conservative Swift Current—Grasslands—Kindersley, SK

Is there any concern, with the way the government is pursuing its nuclear strategy, that they might be putting a bit of weight on the scale towards one technology over another technology, or do you feel that the current approach is going to allow that flexibility?

5:25 p.m.

Senior Adviser, X-energy Canada

Steve Coupland

I think the government has done a pretty good job of putting out a solid nuclear energy strategy, something we in the industry have asked for a long time. We were pleased to see the reference to advanced reactors in there and our ability to do stuff. The reality is, like any strategy, it's implementation that counts, and there's a lot of work to be done on that front.

Again, the implementation is the challenge. In our case, it's helping us get the initial project off the ground. First-of-a-kind projects have some challenges. We need that assistance and support from the government.

One of the things we'd like to see is the extension of the clean energy ITCs until 2040. Give us a bit more time for first-of-a-kind projects. The other thing I would say the government is doing that we support is making low-cost loans available through the Canada Infrastructure Bank, and we support the continued funding of the first nation infrastructure fund, all of which are helpful.

5:25 p.m.

Chief of Staff International—Nuclear, AtkinsRéalis

Sam Boutziouvis

May I make a contribution, Mr. Chair?

The Chair Liberal Terry Duguid

Mr. Patzer.