Through you, Madam Chair, sir, those are talking points. I need to know whether you had discussions about stock buybacks, dividends and CEO bonuses. If so, did you make a recommendation to cabinet? You don't have to tell me what the recommendation was, but I need to give you an example. This program provided $120 million in public money to Imperial Oil and then let them pay out $324 million in dividends to their rich shareholders. I need to know, in terms of your reasonableness for the applications, whether you provided cabinet with recommendations on the dividends and the bonuses.
