You're being asked...it's between apples and oranges. They're both bad. As for the year detention, we worked for years, before we went up to the Supreme Court of Canada in Charkaoui, to get rid of the arbitrary detention. We won in front of the Supreme Court of Canada. They said you cannot have a detention without a review. There has to be a review of the need to detain.
So what does the government do? It now proposes a new law that puts people in detention without a review of the need to detain. It's like a slap in the face to the Supreme Court of Canada in terms of its judgment in Charkaoui. You should look at that judgment.
Asking me if it is better to have a GPS than to keep people in jail for a year...if they're not needed in either instance, there's no way I'm going to say yes to that. Unless it's justified that there is a need for a GPS or a need for detention, I don't support either. It's wrong.