Evidence of meeting #18 for Public Safety and National Security in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was c-8.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Robertson  Senior Research Associate, Citizen Lab, University of Toronto, As an Individual
de Boer  Vice-President, Government Relations, BlackBerry
Hatfield  Executive Director, OpenMedia
Warnell  Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power
Bradley  President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

I still have a bit of time.

You were saying that Bill C‑8 poses risks to your partnership with the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security. Could you tell us a bit, in 30 seconds, what the problem is in that regard?

12:40 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

Francis Bradley

That's really an unintended consequence of the bill. In the electricity sector and other critical infrastructure sectors, we benefit from a very co‑operative relationship with the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security. What we want is to preserve that relationship.

The short answer is that we have a very, very strong information-sharing relationship now. This will clearly have a chilling effect if there's even the possibility that information that's being shared could wind up in the hands of regulators.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

Thank you, Mr. Bradley.

I now give the floor to Ms. Kirkland for five minutes.

No, wait, I misspoke. Mr. Au is next.

12:40 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

Good. Thank you.

I have questions for Mr. Warnell.

You mentioned private-public partnerships. I think this is a really good idea. On cybersecurity issues, there are technical parts and components to do with technology. I always believe that government does not have the most timely information or technological knowledge. This bill gives the power to the minister to tell the industry what to do and what not to do. I don't think that's the best approach. You guys know better. You're on the ground.

What are your comments in response to having to receive directions from the minister on what to do and what not to do? What is your response to that?

12:45 p.m.

Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power

Todd Warnell

The structure of the legislation from our perspective is actually adequate, because it is setting up for “speed of response”. The minister themselves will not unilaterally act and provide some arbitrary direction to an industry or an industry participant. They will be working hand in hand with private-public entities. They will be working with and taking technical advice from the Canadian centre for cybersecurity. We don't see the arbitrary nature of an individual minister posing a risk.

When a disruptive or destructive action is about to happen, the opportunity to respond with speed is of the utmost importance. The legislation as laid out allows for that speed of response. It doesn't say to ignore technical experts. It doesn't say to move unilaterally. It is set up for speed of response, which, as we know, in the cybersecurity landscape is of the utmost importance to prevent and/or respond to an event that's unfolding.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

Very good.

In your presentation, you also mentioned that Bill C-8 is well intended and needed. Why do you believe, or do you believe, that the bill itself would address most of the problems?

12:45 p.m.

Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power

Todd Warnell

I'll build off your question from the previous session.

Candidly, this never ends. With regard to the cyber-threat landscape that is evolving, there is no end. With regard to your previous comment to the last panel, this is a first step. There will be next steps. There will be forever steps. This is because the technology, the capabilities and the cyber-threat landscape will continue to evolve. We're talking and dealing with technologies that are currently mass deployed. We know that AI continues to accelerate now. That is really at a level of focus well before this legislation even came into being in its predecessor form, as Bill C-26.

The reason this bill as it's structured is important is that it doesn't lay out specifically the technologies, the approach or the capabilities that are needed to respond. It is purposefully wide and broad, because we know that it will only continue to evolve very rapidly. That ability of the legislation causes consternation and challenge. I know a lot of industry partners and sectors would like very clear lines of delineation and specificity, but that would undermine the ability to adjust to changing threat landscapes, changing capabilities and changing tactics being used around the world.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

Again, obviously, we shouldn't play the game of trying to catch up.

If there is one thing you can recommend so that we can be more proactive, so that we can be ahead of the criminals, what would you recommend?

December 4th, 2025 / 12:45 p.m.

Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power

Todd Warnell

Again, I would recommend continuing to embolden those public-private partnerships, which do exist today. Further indoctrinate those as mandatory elements of coordination and collaboration between government and technical authorities, as well as the competent private sector authorities. That would be my single, best recommendation.

12:45 p.m.

Conservative

Chak Au Conservative Richmond Centre—Marpole, BC

That's very good.

My next question is for Mr. Bradley.

I understand that in regulations and also all kinds of reporting procedures.... You have the professional body. You have the professional industry standard that is already set up. This is another layer that the government is trying to put forward.

Do you agree that, if the industry standard is already higher than the required government standard, it would be better to have the government adopt the professional standard or allow the professional standard to prevail, instead of setting another layer? Would you agree to that?

12:45 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

Francis Bradley

I would agree entirely. That's precisely what we would like to see in this case. We're currently operating under—

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

I'm sorry for interrupting, Mr. Bradley. My job is not easy when I have to interrupt people who are providing answers.

Thank you very much, Mr. Au.

I now give the floor to Ms. Acan for five minutes.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Mr. Warnell, I had the privilege to visit Bruce Power this summer. I want to start by thanking you for the very hard work on the electricity sector and for being the global leader in nuclear usage in medicine for both single-use device sterilization as well as a first-of-its-kind isotope production system. That's used for cancer treatment. You're helping hundreds of thousands of patients.

Ontario produces about 30% of its electricity from Bruce Power, and Ontario contributes around 40% of Canada's GDP. Ensuring a reliable energy supply is a key factor in maintaining our country's economic and national security. Given the critical role that Bruce Power plays in Ontario's electrical supply, why is it essential to protect Canada's critical infrastructure from cyber-threats and other malicious actors?

My second question is this: How does Bill C-8 address these risks?

12:50 p.m.

Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power

Todd Warnell

I will start off by saying that Bruce Power's having the ability to continue to operate, provide electricity and stay online, given the defence and depth posture and practices that we have related to security, means nothing if our product can't be delivered to Canadians. It means nothing if it can't get to powering devices in telco or in transportation to allow Canadians to move and communicate around the country. Bruce Power is not an island. We are an essential critical asset, but our product needs to be consumed through the use of electricity throughout the industry.

The importance of this legislation is not about actually improving practices, much as Mr. Bradley was saying. The electricity sector writ large has had mature cybersecurity approaches for two decades or more. Fundamentally, the collective system of systems is vulnerable. The frailty exists in the downstream. Moving and bringing the operating floor and requirement for cybersecurity programs and practices and for supplier risk management to a common level is absolutely in the best interests of all Canadians. I'm not here in the interest today of Bruce Power. I'm here in the interest of making sure that the electricity and the isotopes can get to the places that need them, especially in times of crisis or disruption.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much.

Mr. Bradley, do you want to add anything on that?

12:50 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

Francis Bradley

Sure.

The interdependencies are probably the critical question in this. They always have been, at least from our perspective, as the legislation was first being discussed and as it evolved, really, over the past decade. We were involved in some of those early discussions and were in favour of some kind of legislation, given that the electricity sector, at a bulk level, has mandatory critical infrastructure protection and cybersecurity standards.

Our concern has always been the other interdependent pieces of the economy and supply chain that deliver services to end customers. What about transportation? What about telecommunications? What about finance? They're dependent upon us. We're dependent upon them. We know that our house is in order, but we do have questions about the other sectors.

A broad piece of legislation like this gives us the ability to have a greater assurance that the broader critical infrastructure is being protected. We've always been in favour of seeing this move forward, because of those interdependency concerns.

Sima Acan Liberal Oakville West, ON

Thank you very much.

Mr. Warnell, following the recent emergency preparedness exercise simulating a cyber-attack at Bruce Power, how are Canada's critical infrastructure operators currently prepared to respond to cyber-threats, including at Bruce Power, and in what ways does Bill C-8 enhance their capabilities and provide additional tools for resilience?

12:50 p.m.

Chief Information Security Officer, Bruce Power

Todd Warnell

We were very pleased with the first-of-a-kind evolution of an exercise of that scale, called Huron Unity, which we just completed here in mid-November and had previously focused, based on our regulation, on nuclear security or a nuclear safety challenge. We embedded, for the first time ever, an actual digital disruption event into that as well, to ensure that we can continue to learn and advance towards excellence around multi-scale or multi-faceted events.

The reality of Bill C-8 and why that's important, to extend what we did, is that it will make it acceptable and the prevailing practice of all critical infrastructure sectors to view cybersecurity as not just a sidecar. It's no longer a separate domain. It is essential to business continuity and ensuring that we can drive the outcome.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

Thank you, Mr. Warnell. I apologize once again for having to stop you when your comments are very interesting.

It's now my turn to have the floor for two and a half minutes.

Mr. Bradley, I felt you were a bit rushed earlier. Could you tell me about the importance of the partnership you have with the Canadian Centre for Cyber Security? It is important to fully understand the implications of Bill C‑8 on that partnership.

12:55 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

Francis Bradley

As I mentioned earlier, we have a very deep relationship with the cyber centre and with the officials. We were one of the first sectors the cyber centre began working closely with. Many of my members, both at the CEO and CIO levels, have security clearances and participate in classified briefings and discussions. In fact, even this week, we had a group in town.

By the same token, there was a great deal of information being shared in that classified space about the challenges and some of the events that are taking place within the sector. It has been a very effective information-sharing relationship. It is a model that I know they're looking at for other sectors for effective information sharing.

Fundamentally, my concern about the legislation would be around whether this results in, as I said earlier, that “chilling effect” of this very effective information sharing that has been developed at both the unclassified and classified levels over many years and could be damaged. We've seen a great deal of value for the sector as a result of those conversations, but so has the cyber centre and, really, critical infrastructure as a whole. The more the folks at the cyber centre are able to learn about the challenges within the sector, the more they'll be able to help other sectors as well.

Those information-sharing channels are absolutely critical, and I would be very concerned about anything that would damage something that we've spent a lot of time looking at, developing and building.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

There is a risk that partners would withhold certain information for fear that it would be misused. Is that correct?

12:55 p.m.

President and Chief Executive Officer, Electricity Canada

Francis Bradley

Absolutely, and that is a concern that we had two decades ago, as NERC was being stood up and we began having mandatory standards as opposed to simply none.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

Thank you, Mr. Bradley. Even when it's my turn, I have to interrupt you when my time is up.

I now give the floor to Mr. Caputo for five minutes.

12:55 p.m.

Conservative

Frank Caputo Conservative Kamloops—Thompson—Nicola, BC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I would like to begin my time by moving a motion that was put on notice. It has been distributed in both official languages, and I hope all members have had a chance to read it. It's simple and straightforward, and hopefully it can pass quickly with the unanimous support of all colleagues. Then we can get back to committee business.

I don't believe I have to read the motion into the record, because it has been distributed. That's all of my commentary at this time.

Thank you.

The Vice-Chair Bloc Claude DeBellefeuille

You're officially moving the motion that you put on notice, Mr. Caputo, and now you want to discuss it. Is that correct?