Evidence of meeting #53 for Status of Women in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was data.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Emily Laidlaw  Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual
Richardson  Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection
Lee  Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network
Jad Sinno  Director, Research, Community-Based Research Centre
Matyas  Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council
Kim  Senior Staff Lawyer, Women's Legal Education and Action Fund

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

Mr. Richardson, it's the same question.

11:40 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

If I could personally have my way, I think it would be to re-envision the rules and regs. It seems like we threw away the rules and regs when large models were being trained in the first place.

A lot of these large models were essentially predicated on a lot of illegal activity to start with. Whether it be training on child sexual abuse material, non-consensual intimate images or simply copyright material, it proliferates in all of these large models. It was illegal to start. Now we're in this bad position. I would argue that we need to take a step back and say, “The rules we had in place weren't adhered to. Are we now just accepting that this is the new reality?” I take issue with that.

I'll go back to what I said earlier relating to accountability. You have to be accountable. The way these AI models work, it's not like you can seek to have everything fit under section 230 in the U.S. In terms of the outputs of these, we accept that no one's responsible for them, because it's not an individual. It needs to be attributed to the companies using them. There was an Air Canada example where one of their agents was discussing a flight with a customer: Here's the price. Air Canada went back on it. Well, no, that's not acceptable. If you're going to use AI in this way, you need to be responsible for the actions that come out of them.

I think both are actually important. One is probably a little more likely than the other in terms of the genie being out of the bottle, but there you have it.

Marilyn Gladu Liberal Sarnia—Lambton—Bkejwanong, ON

Thank you for that.

Ms. Lee, a question was asked about whether children's mental health is being affected because of the situation. You said it's already here. I was astounded to hear, when I was in debate on Bill C‑34, that the number of child exploitations that the police were investigating was 19,591 last year, up 500% from 2014. Postpandemic, depression amongst the youth has doubled, anxiety has tripled and suicide has quadrupled.

You seem to know something about practices in other parts of the world. What best practices that other countries are doing would you suggest we put in place here in Canada?

11:45 a.m.

Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network

Vivian Lee

I would recommend, first off, looking toward Switzerland. They've recently produced the brand new Euria LLM. It is artificial intelligence that is self-sovereign, localized and environmentally flat, with no impact on their environment. It is owned and operated by the federal government of the country. It has the guardrails and community safety supports that they believe match their local sovereignty standards.

There are countries that are actively already building systems like this. We should follow suit. China has also implemented local sovereign systems. I believe we are so far behind that we need to jump forward and start looking at predictive options.

In terms of mental health in our youth communities, I'd say that was an under-reported dataset for what you mentioned earlier. I believe that number to be much higher. As we know, only a fraction of incidents are actually reported. I don't believe students have the capacity right now to access resources or even know how to ask for help.

11:45 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Ms. Lee.

I now give the floor to Ms. Larouche for two and a half minutes.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Once again, witnesses, thank you for being with us today. It's extremely informative to hear you speak, Mr. Richardson, Ms. Lee and Ms. Laidlaw. You all seem to agree that Bill C‑34 must be passed.

Ms. Laidlaw, you talked about interoperability between Canada and other countries. As we know, artificial intelligence has no borders, but what about interoperability between the federal government, which would pass Bill C‑34, and the provinces and Quebec, which have areas of jurisdiction that are affected by this issue? These include youth protection and education, in particular.

The Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage even recommended that the Government of Canada, in addressing the impact of influencers and social media on children and teenagers, recognize the jurisdiction and primacy of provincial authority over social problems and youth protection by adopting an asymmetrical and flexible approach.

Do you think Bill C‑34 is sufficiently asymmetrical and flexible?

11:45 a.m.

Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual

Dr. Emily Laidlaw

I think that Bill C-34 is only the start.

Because of the division of powers, there's a really important role for provinces to play, in particular when it comes to health and education, and also, some of the more specific civil-type harms that are normally within the jurisdiction of a province.

If I could fast forward five years, what I would imagine that we should have in place is we'd have a federal digital safety commission, and we're going to have provincial digital safety commissions as well. We have similar models in existence right now with our privacy commissioners, who often collaborate on different dimensions of these problems. I think this is the way we're going to have to look at this going forward, because there's no way that we can fully address the impacts of AI and the really acute on-the-ground harms that we're seeing without collaboration between the federal government and provincial partners.

11:45 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Ms. Laidlaw.

Ms. Roberts, you have the floor for five minutes.

11:45 a.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

Thank you, Madam Chair, and thank you to the witnesses.

I'd like to start off with Mr. Richardson.

You mentioned deepfakes, and I'm a little concerned about those. They've gone up to 100,000 so far this year. My concern is images of children.

As a mother and a grandmother, I am concerned about the future of our children. One of my main priorities while I'm here on the Hill is combatting human trafficking. We know that many predators use the Internet to source their victims. Do you feel that AI potentially has a role to play in finding these traffickers, bringing them to justice and keeping children safe from them, or do you feel that AI being used in this way would do more harm than good?

11:50 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

It's a good question.

It's a very similar answer to how I'd talk about technology in general. These things tend to be double-edged swords. While we talked about many of the harms related to artificial intelligence and the specific harms related to women and children, there are also utilities for it. For example, AI is at the heart of many facial matching things, which again is a double-edged sword. It's good for identification of victims and potentially offenders. However, it also has some privacy implications to it.

I would weigh in that the harms that have been brought along by AI definitely outweigh the good things, but it's good for us to be focusing, certainly, on the sides of AI that are absolutely useful to help protect any sort of marginalized community.

11:50 a.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

I want to go back to that for a minute. Twenty-two per cent of individuals who are trafficked are children under the age of 18. Ninety-three per cent are women. Out of that 93%, 22% are children. Human trafficking in general is an industry that is in excess of $200 billion U.S. It's becoming one of the largest criminal activities in the world.

Do you not feel that the AI companies and the high-tech companies that create the AI should be regulated to ensure that our children's safety comes first?

11:50 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

Absolutely. I think they should be regulated beyond that. The child safety aspect is the lowest bar that we're looking for here. When we see harm exacted on children in ways that these companies could have and should have known better—or in some cases we see just outright negligence—that's the lowest bar we should look at for these companies, outside of the other harms related to the use of these technologies that we're seeing.

11:50 a.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

I'm going to ask you a personal question. Do you feel that predators should be sentenced to the maximum sentence of the law?

11:50 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

Generally speaking? It's a very nuanced question. Do I think that sentencing is adequate in all cases? Absolutely not. I think, when we look at abuse, particularly related to children, we need to look at what.... The punishment is an important thing, but I think the side question there is, we're looking for the public safety and further harm to children that can be caused by someone like that. If incarceration is the partial answer to that, I think that, yes, it absolutely needs to be looked at, because public safety, in particular child safety, is the paramount thing that we're talking about here.

11:50 a.m.

Conservative

Anna Roberts Conservative King—Vaughan, ON

The reason I'm asking that is I recently met with a mother of a child with Asperger's. The child was groomed through social media. She finally found her after five years, and she's now on suicide watch.

That perpetrator, in my view, has destroyed a human being. That perpetrator should never be allowed out of jail. What are your thoughts on that?

11:50 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

There's a mix of things there. I will put the jail thing aside. Edging back to my previous comment about what we look at in terms of the safeguards going forward, knowing that we can't, with our current system, necessarily keep someone like that in jail forever, we need to look at how there is no harm going forward.

The particular example you gave relates to someone having Internet access. There are failures there. If we presume that the person is getting out of jail at some point, what are those factors we're looking at after the fact, where we can prevent harm. I think that's important.

There's also the tech-facilitated nature of that particular—

11:50 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, sir.

Ms. Lambropoulos, you have the floor for five minutes.

Emmanuella Lambropoulos Liberal Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'd like to begin by thanking our witnesses for being here, for speaking to such an important issue today, for raising awareness and for helping us come up with good recommendations for this study.

I'm going to begin with Mr. Richardson.

You spoke about how victims of sexual violence are often retraumatized and that often their photos are the ones that are then turned into deepfakes. It's predators who are looking at these photos, and obviously social media companies are allowing this to happen.

Some members of Parliament here have asked and insinuated what some of the risks to the children are. I'm hoping that you can share with us, through what you've witnessed, what the consequences actually are once a child has had this happen. If government doesn't act and doesn't put the necessary tools in place, where does this end up going for these kids?

11:55 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

There's a whole range of examples that we see in this space.

In the most egregious examples, it's not just the imagery. It's that the imagery gets into communities of individuals who want to know more about the victims in terms of where they live, where they work and all of those things. It turns into an unwanted celebrity status amongst some of these women, which is very gendered and targeted. We see that behaviour far more directed toward adolescent girls.

We also see it going forward into life. It's not just a temporary thing where you see the abuse now. We'll get people coming in to us 10 years after this has happened, because they're looking for a job and all of a sudden their results are coming up in a search engine. There are images of them as a child with...child sexual abuse that an employer might come across. That's a sort of reality, because of the amplification of these things when they're shared in some of these communities.

The harms here are off the charts in terms of what these victims have to endure.

Emmanuella Lambropoulos Liberal Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you very much for that answer.

I'm going to ask both of the witnesses who are still with us today to respond to the next question. I'll start with Mr. Richardson and then move to Ms. Lee.

You've spoken a lot in favour of Bill C-34, which would require social media companies to make harmful content, including child sexual abuse material and non-consensual intimate images, inaccessible. What will it take for these companies to listen? How can countries work together to entice companies to act or have them at least comply with the policies that are already in place?

11:55 a.m.

Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection

Lloyd Richardson

That's a good question. I might highlight some behaviours of some of these companies that we've seen historically, which really point in the direction of them not wanting to do it, or doing a half job of it.

For example, X and Elon Musk, etc., were ordered to remove materials that the B.C. tribunal suggested were non-consensual intimate images. Essentially, all X did was restrict Canadians' access. The rest of the world can see these illegal images, but they're restricted in Canada. We have some real cross-jurisdictional issues with this.

We touched earlier on the notion of Canada being bold. Let's talk about sovereign law. These tech companies are not bigger than Canada, and we have mechanisms that we can put in place whereby we say, “No, you cannot do this and there are going to be consequences within Canada”, whether that looks like financial penalties or even just the restriction of use within the country.

There are other countries that are getting to the same page on this, but we have to acknowledge that there will be corners of the Internet that aren't going to adhere to Canadian sovereign law. We need to think about how we, as a country, bulk up our law so that it's adhered to by some of these unscrupulous companies.

Emmanuella Lambropoulos Liberal Saint-Laurent, QC

Thank you.

Vivian, would you like to add to that?

11:55 a.m.

Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network

Vivian Lee

I believe there should be financial penalties for these tech companies that are excessive enough so that they pay attention.

11:55 a.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Ms. Lee. I'm sorry, but that's all the time we have. As the disciplinarian, I have to follow procedure, because we have another group of witnesses coming in.

Witnesses, thank you from the bottom of my heart for giving us your time today. It was very informative. I think all of my colleagues have really enjoyed our discussions.

We will suspend for a few moments.

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

I call the meeting back to order.

I'd like to remind witnesses that committee members may ask questions in either French or English. If you will need interpretation, please take a moment now to prepare your earpiece and select the listening channel required in order to take full advantage of the time allotted for questions and answers.

Please click on the microphone icon to activate your mic and mute yourself when you are not speaking.

If you wish to speak, simply indicate as such or use the “raise hand” function.

I will now welcome our witnesses.

From the Community-Based Research Centre, we have Jad Sinno, director of research. From the Information and Communications Technology Council, we have Lissa Matyas, vice-president of capacity building and innovation. From the Women’s Legal Education and Action Fund, we have Rosel Kim, senior staff lawyer.

Welcome. We will begin with opening statements.

Dr. Sinno, the floor is yours for five minutes, please.