Evidence of meeting #53 for Status of Women in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was data.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Emily Laidlaw  Canada Research Chair in Cybersecurity Law and Professor, Faculty of Law, University of Calgary, As an Individual
Richardson  Director, Technology, Canadian Centre for Child Protection
Lee  Director, Education and Strategy, Open Digital Literacy and Access Network
Jad Sinno  Director, Research, Community-Based Research Centre
Matyas  Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council
Kim  Senior Staff Lawyer, Women's Legal Education and Action Fund

12:25 p.m.

Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council

Lissa Matyas

I don't think it's possible for any one country to be completely data sovereign, not even the U.S. I think that we need to look at priorities, perhaps how the data is routed and who touches your data. To my colleague's point, we need to make sure that the people whose data is going to be included are consulted about how their data is stored, routed, used, etc. I think a top priority for the federal government is to really understand the routing process, the telecom and the cloud computing resources.

There's the infrastructure piece, the telecom piece and other sorts of data security pieces that I think we need to really dive into, being realistic about the fact that completely managing the full AI tech stack is probably unrealistic.

Chi Nguyen Liberal Spadina—Harbourfront, ON

Thank you.

I think I have time for one more question.

12:30 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Ask it very quickly.

Chi Nguyen Liberal Spadina—Harbourfront, ON

Ms. Matyas, on the numbers you talked about in terms of women and the impact on the workforce, where are young women right now? Is there a fear around the role that AI is going to play in terms of potentially taking away jobs? You talked about the pivot to being more efficient, but where are young people today on this and young women in particular?

12:30 p.m.

Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council

Lissa Matyas

I think there's a real fear because Canada's youth unemployment is at precariously high levels, higher than in many decades, the last several decades. I think we really need to focus on training programs and equipping young women with the opportunity—

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Thank you, Ms. Matyas. I'm sorry to have to cut you off.

Ms. Larouche, you have the floor for six minutes.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I'm taking copious notes. Thank you to the witnesses, Jad Sinno, Rosel Kim and Lissa Matyas, for being with us today.

Ms. Matsyas, what you just said is true. We had a discussion in the House last week about the report of the Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities regarding its study on the youth unemployment rate. One of the things the federal government should be concerned about is the risks posed by artificial intelligence, as well as the link between AI and the problem of youth employment. I mentioned it in my speech in the House. Thank you for raising it.

My first question is for Ms. Kim.

We talked about the fact that the legislation stemming from Bill C‑16 opened the door to criminalizing deepfakes. It covers that issue. Even so, we see that the numbers are increasing. Is it because the new act is not well enough known? Is it because it lacks teeth? What is missing from the legislation that would allow it to address deepfakes? Does it just take time for the new legislation to become known?

12:30 p.m.

Senior Staff Lawyer, Women's Legal Education and Action Fund

Rosel Kim

I think it's a bit of both.

We need to see how the law in Bill C-16 is interpreted and applied by the judges to see what will be caught under Bill C-16. I think some of the questions we might have are about a deepfake of someone that has an obvious feature that makes it very obvious it's not a depiction of them, so that it's not likely to be mistaken as their image—like if a third eye was added—but it's still a sexualized deepfake. What would happen?

I think we still have some questions, and we will need to see how it is applied.

In terms of other responses, I talked about the direct support for survivors that some, but not all, provinces have. Having that kind of direct support would be really important for survivors. Also, it's just about making sure that the technology is not so widely available or that there is a quick takedown of these images when they do surface. I think those are some of the responses.

Some of this is in Bill C-34 as well, under the companies' responsibilities to respond to certain content, including non-consensually shared intimate images. I think it's a question of time, but we always need more support and other kinds of remedies outside of the criminal realm, including the civil realm, and we need easy takedowns that don't require always going to the legal system, which can be very slow.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

My next question is also for you, Ms. Kim.

In your opening remarks, you also said that adequate resources and expertise would be needed to implement Bill C‑34. The Standing Committee on Canadian Heritage, which studied the bill, was also concerned about expertise.

You just talked about the importance of victim support. We know that the administration of justice, for one, falls under the jurisdiction of Quebec and the provinces. Community organizations that help victims are also under Quebec's responsibility.

After Bill C‑34 is passed, how will we be able to work together to ensure that people have the proper resources and the necessary expertise on the ground, given that there are shared jurisdictions?

Education is one example. How can the different levels of government work together in terms of what each can and should do?

12:35 p.m.

Senior Staff Lawyer, Women's Legal Education and Action Fund

Rosel Kim

Yes. I think there will need to be co-operation and collaboration between the provinces and the federal government. The mandate of the digital safety commission is very broad and it's tackling a lot of different issues. There's the need for the commission itself to be well resourced and also to represent the different expertise needed, especially expertise on human rights, inequality, gender-based violence and what counts as gender-based violence.

I heard Professor Emily Laidlaw speak about this. We have the model of provincial privacy commissioners working with a federal privacy commissioner. I think a similar kind of a collaborative relationship would need to exist to tackle the really big issues and harms we are seeing.

Andréanne Larouche Bloc Shefford, QC

There are only 35 seconds left. I'll quickly go to you, Mr. Sinno.

What initiative related to the impact on communities can the government put forward, particularly to help the organizations that support them?

12:35 p.m.

Director, Research, Community-Based Research Centre

Dr. Jad Sinno

Yes, absolutely. Thank you for this question.

I think the first thing is to ensure that there is meaningful integration with a seat at the table that includes authority and decision-making power—

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Sir, I must cruelly interrupt you.

12:35 p.m.

Director, Research, Community-Based Research Centre

Dr. Jad Sinno

Thank you. No worries.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

The Chair Conservative Dominique Vien

Ms. Borrelli, the floor is yours for five minutes.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Kathy Borrelli Conservative Windsor—Tecumseh—Lakeshore, ON

Witnesses, I'd like to thank you for your time today. I appreciate your expert testimony.

My first question is for Lissa Matyas.

What are the particular sectors, industries or jobs where women face greater risks of unequal treatment because of AI?

12:35 p.m.

Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council

Lissa Matyas

They are very exposed to AI adoption.

On the point of training, we need to train people who are in areas like bookkeeping, payroll administration and other areas where generative AI is increasing productivity and eliminating these jobs. Also, entry-level positions are being greatly affected by AI.

I think programs like work-integrated learning activities for recent graduates and current students are really important, so they can actually expand beyond their current set of skills and responsibilities in their current jobs. It's not necessarily eliminating the job altogether, but it's changing the nature of work. Without upskilling and re-skilling people to be able to take on new tasks within their current role, or potentially having AI creating whole new business lines that these current employees can move into, then women can be disproportionately affected.

12:35 p.m.

Conservative

Kathy Borrelli Conservative Windsor—Tecumseh—Lakeshore, ON

Are women disproportionately represented in occupations that are more vulnerable to AI? What measures could be implemented to mitigate the effects?

12:35 p.m.

Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council

Lissa Matyas

They certainly are.

A lot of these roles are disproportionately represented by women. The ones that I gave examples of are bookkeeping, payroll administration or other areas like that. They are really the first line of attack for AI.

I think employers have to be part of the conversation about how we can upskill and how AI adoption can be done in a way that actually can create more jobs for the company rather than eliminating the jobs of their current employees. Upskilling and re-skilling will be an important part of the national AI strategy, from my perspective.

As I mentioned, I think this is an opportunity to bring in universities and experts to look at business lines. Rather than just increasing individual productivity, really look at how the company can grow, how we can create more jobs and more anchor companies in Canada. Rather than being a branch-plant economy, we can really scale up companies and use AI in a positive way rather than eliminate these current jobs.

12:40 p.m.

Conservative

Kathy Borrelli Conservative Windsor—Tecumseh—Lakeshore, ON

Ms. Matyas, how can the government and industry collect the proper data that shows evidence about discrimination outcomes while protecting personal privacy?

12:40 p.m.

Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council

Lissa Matyas

I think that's a really important issue.

I think some of my colleagues have pointed to the data gaps. There is a really important role to play for gender-diverse individuals and others, like indigenous populations, to be included in how the data will be collected. It's really important that there's consultation in terms of how the information will be gathered and who will manage and own the data.

We have to start within communities and really have these conversations now. They're very difficult conversations to have, sometimes. I think we need to arrive at an area where, potentially, the data is owned not by the government and shared more nationally, but by these communities.

12:40 p.m.

Conservative

Kathy Borrelli Conservative Windsor—Tecumseh—Lakeshore, ON

Yes.

Who do you think should be responsible for implementing these safeguards and guardrails?

12:40 p.m.

Vice-President, Capacity Building and Innovation, Information and Communications Technology Council

Lissa Matyas

I think it's a collective effort. I don't think it's one organization or one individual. We've talked a lot about provincial versus federal, but I think the communities really have a major role to play. They really understand their own concerns and their own priorities. We need to find a way to work together.

AI is affecting everybody on the planet. I think there's even a more global international element in terms of responsible AI.

12:40 p.m.

Conservative

Kathy Borrelli Conservative Windsor—Tecumseh—Lakeshore, ON

Thank you.

Ms. Kim, how can a policy-maker distinguish between discrimination arising from AI use and discrimination that is not supported by AI use?

12:40 p.m.

Senior Staff Lawyer, Women's Legal Education and Action Fund

Rosel Kim

This also points to some of the risks of AI systems being so embedded into some of our systems. That often is then used as a justification or an excuse for the companies that have these AI systems to not reveal who made that decision—