Thank you.
I'd like to thank the committee for inviting me to speak today. I look forward to initiating a dialogue with you about the optimum methods of improving the health of our Canadian Forces and veterans.
Canada should be proud of the efforts that have been made over the last ten years in improving the mental health care system for our service members and our veterans. However, Canadian policy-makers will need to foster strong partnerships across academic and government sectors to face the challenges of providing care for veterans who have had combat experiences in Afghanistan in the context of limited resources.
During this presentation, I'll present my background and experience to help you understand the context of my comments. I'll also provide a story that highlights some of the key issues that our system needs to consider. Then I'll describe some of the important work that our group has done, and end with future directions.
I'm an adult psychiatrist working in the Veterans Affairs operational stress injury clinic in Winnipeg, Manitoba. I'm also professor of psychiatry and director of research at the University of Manitoba, and chair of the science committee at the Canadian Psychiatric Association.
My research work has been supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, the Manitoba Health Research Council, and the Canadian Institute for Military and Veteran Health Research.
To illustrate the important issues we're facing, I'll describe a case. This case is a composite of several people who I've treated so as not to breach confidentiality and potentially identify any single individual.
A 25-year-old service member is referred to our OSI clinic for assessment and treatment. The member presents with nightmares, sleep problems, irritability, and thoughts about suicide. He remembers being thrown from his vehicle, during his tour in Afghanistan, because of an explosion. His fellow soldier was killed instantly during the explosion. He lost consciousness and broke his leg. He spent many weeks recovering from the physical injury.
Since returning home nine months ago, he has been avoiding activities with his wife and children due to depression. He feels enormous amounts of guilt, and wonders whether he could have done something to help save his fellow soldier.
He's been binge-drinking alcohol on weekends to numb the memories and control the physical pain he is having and to try to improve his sleep. His marriage is falling apart.
The story that you've just heard is a common one that many of us working in the operational stress injury clinics across Canada hear on a daily basis. As you can imagine, the emotional costs of deployment to Afghanistan have been substantial for Canada. Not only do problems like post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, and alcohol abuse impact on the individual and their families, these issues have a strong impact on the military, veterans, and our society.
There are some important questions raised by these stories. How many Canadian service members have developed mental health problems related to their deployment? Why does one person who faces combat develop mental health problems while another does not? Who among service members is at risk for developing mental health problems? What can be done to reduce mental illness in our service members and veterans? Most importantly, how can we prevent suicide?
Steven Fletcher, Minister of State for Transport and member of Parliament for Charleswood, visited our clinic last year and asked the following question that I didn't have the answer to: are civilians in Canada more or less likely to get appropriate treatment for depression than our veterans? It's an important question, because the military has been previously criticized for not taking care of the emotional needs of our veterans.
To date, we don't have scientific data to answer many of the questions that I've posed to you. Through important partnerships, through researchers, Canadian Forces, and veterans, we have aimed to try to address some of these important issues.
Our research group began approximately ten years ago. In 2002 Canadian Forces and Statistics Canada conducted a landmark mental health survey to understand the mental health needs of our active military. Stats Canada conducted in-person interviews with over 8,000 active military personnel and tried to understand the mental health needs. We have been supported by the CIHR, the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, over the last ten years to analyze this rich database that's unique in the world.
Here are three key findings from our work.
First, we were inspired by Senator Roméo Dallaire's book, Shake Hands with the Devil. He describes his horrifying experiences as a peacekeeper in Rwanda. He really raised important awareness of post-traumatic stress in Canada.
Second, our research findings demonstrated for the first time that Canadian military personnel acting in peacekeeping roles who experienced combat and witnessed atrocities, such as human massacres, had an increased risk of a range of mental health problems, not just PTSD. However, it's important to note that the majority of mental illness in the military was not related to combat or deployments. Less than 10% of mental illness, if there was a causal link, was related to deployment experiences.
The third main finding from our major study showed that in 2002, untreated mental illness in the military was a common problem. Approximately 50% of people with a diagnosed mental illness, such as depression and anxiety, did not receive care.
The research findings from our work have had substantial scientific and policy impacts. We've published papers from this work in international journals and have presented our findings at national and international conferences, including workshops at NATO on suicide prevention and post-traumatic stress disorder. Two years ago, I was invited to present on suicide risk at the Senate Committee on Veterans Affairs.
Over the last 10 years, the government has taken strong action to improve access and quality of care for our members. They have expanded the Veterans Affairs operational stress injury clinics across Canada. The deployment health section has developed a post-deployment mental health screening survey to provide early and timely access to care for our returning soldiers.
It's important to note that the findings of our work were based on a 2002 mental health survey, which occurred prior to the deployment of ground troops in 2004. Thus, more recent information about the needs of our service members is required, because our recent service members have faced much more combat than ever in history.
I'd like to move towards the partnerships we're working on.
At Queen's University, Dr. Alice Aiken has been leading a Canadian military and veterans health research forum. This brings together universities across Canada and key stakeholders to advance knowledge in the area of military mental health.
I attended the conference last year and have initiated two important partnerships.
First, at this conference, I became aware of the recently collected survey by Stats Canada and Veterans Affairs called “Life after Service”. Our University of Manitoba research group was invited to partner with Dr. Pedlar and his group at Veterans Affairs to address important questions related to mental health. These include household income changes and financial stress in relation to mental illness, and physical health problems and chronic pain in relation to suicidal behaviour.
Second, one of the programs I'm leading is to design a follow-up of the original 2002 Canadian service members survey. I am working on developing partnerships, through funding from Defence Research and Development Canada, the Canadian Forces, and the Mental Health Commission. The original participants will either have become veterans over the last 10 years or will have been sent over to deployment. This would be a unique study in the world. It will address very important questions about pre-deployment, deployment, and post-deployment risk and protective factors for mental illness.
During this presentation, I've tried to give an overview of the important mental health issues faced by our service members. Clearly, there are many more details on each of these issues, which I would be happy to address in the question period.
I would like to end by reminding the committee that the investment in research and other health care areas, such as cardiovascular disease, HIV, and cancer have led to a rapid advancement in knowledge and a reduction in morbidity and mortality in Canada and around the world. I strongly advocate that the need for investment in military mental health research and partnerships can lead to a rapid increase in knowledge and can actually reduce suffering and save lives.
Thank you for listening.