Evidence of meeting #31 for Veterans Affairs in the 45th Parliament, 1st session. (The original version is on Parliament’s site, as are the minutes.) The winning word was pcvrs.

A recording is available from Parliament.

On the agenda

Members speaking

Before the committee

Scharf  Manager, Clinical Services, Broken Squirrel Wellness Ltd.
Thorne  Chief Executive Officer, Veterans Transition Network
Massunken  Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.
Marie Pinard  Physician, As an Individual
Forbes  Registered Psychologist, As an Individual
Morrow  As an Individual

4:55 p.m.

Conservative

Blake Richards Conservative Airdrie—Cochrane, AB

Okay. Hopefully, I'll get a chance to ask that in a future round.

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Next is Mrs. Hirtle for six minutes, please.

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

Thank you, Madam Chair.

Ms. Scharf, I'd like to start with you, please. I understand that you worked for several years at 19 Wing Comox, in recreation and fitness roles. Can you tell us what you observed during that time about the wellness needs of serving members and their families?

4:55 p.m.

Manager, Clinical Services, Broken Squirrel Wellness Ltd.

Mackenzie Scharf

Absolutely. I was PSP staff while I was there, so I will admit that I was limited in my knowledge of what was available for members following their release from the military.

I can speak, again, to being in the fitness area with them. There was a lack of.... At the gym, we had opportunities for veterans to come in and use the services at 19 Wing after they released from the military. We found that there was a disconnect and that, once members did leave, coming back into the gym was triggering. It was very challenging for them to feel a part of the active serving community. As a PSP member, we would get questions, while administering the force tests, for individuals who were not meeting the requirements to continue, or who were exploring medical release.

Personally, I had a lack of knowledge of what was available ongoing after they released, but I certainly saw that there was a disconnect from that community and more of a social isolation once they released from the military.

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

Thank you.

While you were at the base then, what were the day-to-day issues that you saw coming up for both mental and physical health?

4:55 p.m.

Manager, Clinical Services, Broken Squirrel Wellness Ltd.

Mackenzie Scharf

The physical health perspective was probably what I had the most experience with. We would have members who were completing their force test, who were also recovering from chronic injuries from their time in service. We would see them for remedial PT to help support them back to meeting the physical requirements of the testing that we had to administer. Past that point, though, I didn't have any support ongoing with them in that process. It was strictly from the personal training perspective, my time there....

5 p.m.

Liberal

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

That's completely fair. Thanks.

What supports were readily available on base? Were members able to find help off base? Are you aware of that? Do you have any idea?

5 p.m.

Manager, Clinical Services, Broken Squirrel Wellness Ltd.

Mackenzie Scharf

In my role, I was not. It was strictly with the personal training programs and the remedial PT. We did have a PES—a physical exercise specialist—who would support members who had more chronic or complex challenges going on. Again, outside of that physical training role, I was not aware.

5 p.m.

Liberal

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

That's great. Thank you so much.

I'll switch now to Ms. Massunken. I have a couple of questions. Based on your clinical experience, ma'am, including your work at the Department of National Defence, what has your experience been while working with veterans seeking mental health care?

5 p.m.

Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.

Michelle Massunken

I've noticed that the transition piece is one of the things that come up most often—identity, adjusting to life as a civilian, navigating the health care system as a civilian, versus those who were working as active service members. That's one of the main things that I would see, navigating the nuances of being a civilian.

5 p.m.

Liberal

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

I can appreciate that, for sure.

Did you notice similar needs among veterans you had been working with?

5 p.m.

Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.

Michelle Massunken

Absolutely. I think one of the biggest things we explore is grief around identity—“Who am I now?”—and having to navigate simply getting a family doctor, for instance, or even the health care system. Those are things that I have often seen with those I worked with before and that I see with those I work with now.

5 p.m.

Liberal

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

Okay. Thank you.

You also mentioned a virtual program, I believe. Can you explain the differences? What are the differences between an in-person session or program and the virtual program that you would have offered?

5 p.m.

Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.

Michelle Massunken

We're in a stage now where virtual mental health care can be as effective as in-person mental health care. At this point, it's about being able to realize that having access to the support is the most important piece versus no support at all. There are some interventions, perhaps, like EMDR, that are preferably done in person but can be still offered virtually as well.

There are a lot of similarities between virtual and in-person care.

5 p.m.

Liberal

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

Was the acronym EMDR? Can you explain what that means?

5 p.m.

Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.

Michelle Massunken

Yes. EMDR is eye movement desensitization and reprocessing. It does use a couple of different tools, like light bars, but the idea is to engage in bilateral stimulation, and that can be done virtually, by showing the client how to do that on their own.

Alana Hirtle Liberal Cumberland—Colchester, NS

Okay. That's really cool. It sounds cool. I'm more of a meditation kind of gal.

You talked a lot about some of the challenges. In the 30 seconds we have left, are there one or two suggestions you could make that would improve the service?

5 p.m.

Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.

Michelle Massunken

One would be having clear expectations and outlining those clearly to the veterans who are entering the program, in terms of what to expect as you enter or if you decide to enter the rehab program. Managing those expectations, I think, will be very important, as it is on the case manager side, because they often have the initial contact with the veterans before they are entered into the program. Inform the case managers and the veterans very early on what the program is and what the expectations are of the program.

5 p.m.

Liberal

The Chair Liberal Marie-France Lalonde

Thank you very much.

This is for the benefit of our witnesses. The next person, Madame Gaudreau, will address you in French, so I would invite each of you to make sure you use your earpieces and set the audio to the proper language.

Ms. Gaudreau, you have the floor for six minutes.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you, Madam Chair.

I heard Mr. Thorne say that veterans are a unique population.

Ms. Massunken, is that statement true?

5 p.m.

Clinical Director, Mindspa Mental Health Centre Corp.

Michelle Massunken

I would absolutely say they are a unique population. They have a culture of their own, and their experiences are different from those of civilians. I would definitely agree that they are a unique population for many reasons.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Thank you.

Ms. Scharf, what do you think?

5 p.m.

Manager, Clinical Services, Broken Squirrel Wellness Ltd.

Mackenzie Scharf

I would agree as well. From what I see with the veterans we support in the clinic, they are a group of folks who have become incredibly resilient in the job they have done to support our country. What I see is that the resiliency does not directly translate to the workings of day-to-day civilian life, and that poses a lot of challenges for the reintegration back into their day-to-day life.

Marie-Hélène Gaudreau Bloc Laurentides—Labelle, QC

Mr. Thorne, why are veterans a unique population?

Can you expand on that?

5:05 p.m.

Chief Executive Officer, Veterans Transition Network

Oliver Thorne

There are many different ways to look at it.

First and foremost, veterans are a unique population, because they have these deeply unique experiences. The job we ask them to do is unlike any, or many, others that occur in civilian society. We see elements of similarity with culture between those who serve in the Canadian Armed Forces and those who serve as first responders, such as firefighters, paramedics and police, but perhaps where that path can fork is that veterans have a very unique culture.

The process of becoming a soldier is a deeply personal and transformative process of entering into the culture of meeting the needs and the demands of the job, the work they do as a team and the team spirit and collectiveness.

There's one quote I can think of where somebody said, “[W]hen we leave the [Canadian Armed Forces], we find ourselves in a society where the notion of 'we' hardly exists.” It's this idea of moving from a culture and environment where there are such clear expectations around how one behaves and how one interacts.

Another veteran talked about the idea that they could look at somebody's uniform and know everything about them just by looking at that uniform. They could tell where they could serve; they could tell what their rank was and what element they were in. They knew instinctively by looking at somebody's uniform what their relationship was to that person—where they sat within the structure, the hierarchy, the overall mission and the operation of the Canadian Armed Forces. Then they come into civilian life and they try to distinguish one blue suit from another.

Ms. Scharf and Ms. Massunken talked about the idea of transitioning from a highly specific culture and way of life to one that has none of those elements. Comparatively, it's one of absolute chaos and disorder from the perspective of someone who has served, and it is an incredibly difficult psychological and social process for anybody to navigate. Now, let's layer on top of that a traumatic or moral injury, depression, anxiety or PTSD because of the things they've been asked to do or have witnessed overseas in defence of our country or in defence of our freedoms.

Responding to natural disasters here in Canada is an incredibly difficult process, and culture is an enormously important part of connecting with and helping people to navigate that process. If they are not understood, they will not trust. They will not be able to go into those experiences and address the trauma and address what has happened if they do not feel they can trust the person sitting across from them. The trust can emerge only if there is a level of connection and understanding of their experience, which is why military cultural competency is so important.