Mr. Speaker, obviously we have again heard non-answers from a government member to some very direct questions from my colleague from Wild Rose.
The member talked about being on track. Someone needs to wake her up because there has been a derailment. The government is very off track.
The member mentioned broad based tax relief as though the government had actually delivered it. She talked about $16.5 billion of tax relief but, surprise, neglected to mention that the government at the same time has wrung $18 billion out of the Canadian people in tax increases. We talk about the $16 billion of tax relief but we do not mention that we have raised and wrung $18 billion more out of Canadians at the very same time. That is a net loss and the member has the gall to stand in her place and defend her government by saying that it has provided broad based tax relief. How can she do that?