Madam Speaker, I want to thank my colleague opposite for his comments and speech. I found his comments regarding a plan quite interesting.
I would like to take him back about 12 years ago to Kyoto. The government of the time went to Kyoto to sign an international agreement on the back of a napkin without a plan. Even when it came to implementation, it did not even know what it was doing.
Then we get to 2006 and we have seen emissions rise that whole time. Therefore, there was absolutely no plan.
I find it a little bit rich to be lectured on the lack of a plan from the Liberals of that time.
The parliamentary secretary gave a long list of initiatives. We talked about transmission, the east-west grid and our renewable plan.
How does the member have any credibility in talking about a plan when the Liberals did not have a plan on Kyoto?